Silber S, Albrecht A, Göhring S, Kaltenbach M, Kneissl D, Kokott N, Levenson B, Mathey D, Pöhler E, Reifart N, Sauer G, Schofer J, Schwarzbach F
Kardiologische Gemeinschaftspraxis, Klinik Dr. Müller, München.
Herz. 1998 Feb;23(1):47-57. doi: 10.1007/BF03043012.
The German Society for Cardiac Angiography and Interventions in Private Practice has started a registry of cardiac procedures since 1996 in order to establish a standard for performance. Although quality management for the cath lab makes sense and is also legally required, there is no generally recommended infrastructure for quality assurance existing in Germany at this time. Therefore, the German Society of Cardiologists in Private Practice (BNK) initiated a project in 1994 to develop a computer program for paperless documentation of diagnostic cardiac catheterizations and coronary interventions (PTCA) using a minimal data set. In 1996, 8 private associated groups participated in this project. The (anonymous) analysis of 10,316 diagnostic cardiac catheterizations and 2597 PTCA yielded the following results: In 95% of the patients, diagnostic cardiac catheterization was performed using the femoral and in 5% the brachial/radial approach. The mean volume of administered contrast medium was 164 +/- 138 ml/patient. The mean LV-EF was greater than 50% in 58.4% of the patients and between 30% and 50% in 10.1%. Coronary artery disease was diagnosed in 69.6% of the patients and valvular/congenital heart disease in 8.5%. In 18.4% of the patients undergoing diagnostic cardiac catheterizations no significant heart disease was identified. Mortality in the cath lab as well as the rate of cerebral insults was 0.05%. In 22.9% and 19% of the patients PTCA and cardiac surgery respectively was recommended. In patients undergoing PTCA, stable angina was present in 74.4% and unstable angina in 13.1%. Of the total number of PTCA procedures, 5.8% were performed in the setting of acute myocardial infarction. The PTCA lesion success rate was 96%, the mean diameter stenosis was 81% pre and 6% post-intervention. The mortality rate at 1 month post-PTCA was 0.4%, and myocardial infarction 1.0%. An acute occlusion occurred in 1.3% of the PTCA patients; 0.6% had to be transferred for emergency bypass surgery. None of the cath labs had on-site surgery. In comparison to other registries, our data show some similarities but also some different trends. Thus, our newly developed software proved to be reliable, fast and easy to use. Participating centers receive immediate feedback regarding their position within the whole group.
德国私人执业心脏血管造影与介入学会自1996年起开始进行心脏手术登记,以确立手术操作标准。尽管导管室质量管理很有意义且也是法律要求,但目前德国尚无普遍推荐的质量保证基础设施。因此,德国私人执业心脏病学会(BNK)于1994年启动了一个项目,开发一个计算机程序,用于使用最少数据集对诊断性心脏导管插入术和冠状动脉介入治疗(PTCA)进行无纸化记录。1996年,8个私人关联团体参与了该项目。对10316例诊断性心脏导管插入术和2597例PTCA进行的(匿名)分析得出以下结果:95%的患者采用股动脉途径进行诊断性心脏导管插入术,5%采用肱动脉/桡动脉途径。平均造影剂用量为164±138毫升/患者。58.4%的患者左心室射血分数(LV-EF)大于50%,10.1%的患者在30%至50%之间。69.6%的患者被诊断为冠状动脉疾病,8.5%为瓣膜/先天性心脏病。在接受诊断性心脏导管插入术的患者中,18.4%未发现明显心脏病。导管室的死亡率和脑部损伤发生率均为0.05%。分别有22.9%和19%的患者被建议进行PTCA和心脏手术。接受PTCA的患者中,74.4%为稳定型心绞痛,13.1%为不稳定型心绞痛。在所有PTCA手术中,5.8%是在急性心肌梗死情况下进行的。PTCA病变成功率为96%,干预前平均直径狭窄率为81%,干预后为6%。PTCA术后1个月死亡率为0.4%,心肌梗死发生率为1.0%。1.3%的PTCA患者发生急性闭塞;0.6%的患者必须转往急诊进行搭桥手术。没有一个导管室配备现场手术设施。与其他登记数据相比,我们的数据显示出一些相似之处,但也有一些不同趋势。因此,我们新开发的软件被证明是可靠、快速且易于使用的。参与中心能立即得到关于其在整个组内位置的反馈。