Ward M M, Lubeck D, Leigh J P
Medical Service, Veterans Affairs, Palo Alto Health Care System, CA 94304, USA.
J Rheumatol. 1998 Apr;25(4):641-9.
To compare health care utilization and longterm health outcomes among patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) treated in managed care and fee-for-service practice settings.
We compared levels of health care utilization, treatments, and health outcomes between 57 patients with RA treated predominantly in managed care settings and 125 patients with RA treated predominantly in fee-for-service practice settings. These patients were participants in a community based cohort study of health outcomes in RA, and had been followed prospectively for up to 13 years (mean followup 10.3 yrs). Information on physician visits, hospitalizations, diagnostic testing, treatments, and 3 measures of health status (global arthritis status, pain, functional disability measures of the Health Assessment Questionnaire) was collected using biannual mailed questionnaires.
All measures of health care utilization were similar between the managed care and fee-for-service groups, as was the use of the major types of arthritis treatments. Average global arthritis status scores, pain scores, and functional disability scores were closely comparable in the 2 groups. Over time, global arthritis status scores and disability scores worsened in both groups, but the rates of worsening did not differ between groups.
In this cohort, longterm health outcomes, as well as treatments and health care utilization, were similar among persons with RA who were treated in managed care and fee-for-service practice settings.
比较在管理式医疗和按服务收费的医疗环境中接受治疗的类风湿关节炎(RA)患者的医疗服务利用情况和长期健康结局。
我们比较了主要在管理式医疗环境中接受治疗的57例RA患者和主要在按服务收费的医疗环境中接受治疗的125例RA患者的医疗服务利用水平、治疗情况和健康结局。这些患者是一项基于社区的RA健康结局队列研究的参与者,已进行了长达13年的前瞻性随访(平均随访时间为10.3年)。通过每半年邮寄一次的问卷收集有关医生就诊、住院、诊断检查、治疗以及3项健康状况指标(总体关节炎状况、疼痛、健康评估问卷的功能残疾指标)的信息。
管理式医疗组和按服务收费组在所有医疗服务利用指标以及主要类型关节炎治疗的使用方面均相似。两组的平均总体关节炎状况评分、疼痛评分和功能残疾评分密切可比。随着时间的推移,两组的总体关节炎状况评分和残疾评分均恶化,但两组之间的恶化率没有差异。
在这个队列中,在管理式医疗和按服务收费的医疗环境中接受治疗的RA患者在长期健康结局、治疗以及医疗服务利用方面相似。