Prieto M, de Abajo F J, Montero D, Martín-Serrano G, Madurga M, Palop R
Area de Farmacología, Centro Nacional de Farmacobiología, Instituto de Salud Carlos III, Madrid.
Med Clin (Barc). 1998 Feb 28;110(7):247-53.
This study has analysed the trend of antihypertensive drugs consumption in Spain from 1985 to 1995, its economical impact and the correlation with the available scientific evidence. The utilization of calcium channel blockers in the context of the recent controversial about their safety profile was also evaluated.
Drugs from the ATC groups C02, C03 (excluding C03C), C07, C08 (excluding nimodipine and nicardipine) and C09 were included (ATC classification, 1996 version). Drug utilization data and cost figures were obtained from the databases ECOM and FAR-90 of the Ministry of Health. These databases contain the number of packages sold in community pharmacies that are charged to the National Health System. Data are expressed in defined daily doses per 1,000 inhabitants per day (DHD). The cost is expressed in current and constant pesetas.
The use of antihypertensives increased from 34.78 DHD in 1985 to 103.55 DHD in 1995. Angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors (ACEI) and calcium channel blockers (CCB) are responsible for 89% of the total increase. Thiazides and beta-blockers showed a mild increase, although its relative contribution to the total figures declined from 72 to 32% at the end of the period. Rauwolfia alcaloids and antiadrenergic drugs sales were negligible (0.4% of total sales in 1995). Within the thiazides, consumption was concentrated in products containing > or = 50 mg hydrochlorothiazide or equivalent. Enalapril, captopril, nifedipine and the fixed-dose association of hydrochlorothiazide with amiloride were the most widely used drugs. The cost of antihypertensive drugs in current pesetas raised eight times through the study period reaching 105,501 millions pesetas in 1995; 89% of the cost corresponded to ACEI and CCB. Expressed in constant pesetas the cost increase was four fold. The recent controversia about CCB did not have influence on its consumption.
The pattern of use of antihypertensive drugs in Spain does not follow the available scientific evidence. Drugs with less documented effectiveness are the most prescribed; even considering the same effectiveness, efficiency is lower for drugs with higher utilization rates. The available presentations for thiazides makes their utilization in the optimal dosification difficult.
本研究分析了1985年至1995年西班牙抗高血压药物的消费趋势、其经济影响以及与现有科学证据的相关性。还评估了在最近关于钙通道阻滞剂安全性存在争议的背景下其使用情况。
纳入了ATC分类中C02、C03(不包括C03C)、C07、C08(不包括尼莫地平和尼卡地平)和C09组的药物(1996年版ATC分类)。药物利用数据和成本数据来自卫生部的ECOM和FAR - 90数据库。这些数据库包含社区药房销售的、由国家卫生系统收费的药品包装数量。数据以每千居民每日限定日剂量(DHD)表示。成本以现行和恒定比塞塔表示。
抗高血压药物的使用从1985年的34.78 DHD增加到1995年的103.55 DHD。血管紧张素转换酶抑制剂(ACEI)和钙通道阻滞剂(CCB)占总增加量的89%。噻嗪类和β受体阻滞剂有轻微增加,尽管其在总数中的相对贡献在该时期末从72%降至32%。萝芙木生物碱和抗肾上腺素能药物的销售额可忽略不计(1995年占总销售额的0.4%)。在噻嗪类药物中,消费集中在含有≥50毫克氢氯噻嗪或等效物的产品上。依那普利、卡托普利、硝苯地平和氢氯噻嗪与阿米洛利的固定剂量组合是使用最广泛的药物。在研究期间,以现行比塞塔计算的抗高血压药物成本增加了八倍,1995年达到1055.01亿比塞塔;89%的成本对应于ACEI和CCB。以恒定比塞塔表示,成本增加了四倍。最近关于CCB的争议对其消费没有影响。
西班牙抗高血压药物的使用模式与现有科学证据不符。有效性记录较少的药物处方最多;即使考虑相同的有效性,利用率较高的药物效率较低。噻嗪类药物现有的剂型使其难以以最佳剂量使用。