Cantwell M F, McKenna M T, McCray E, Onorato I M
Division of Tuberculosis Elimination, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia 30333, USA.
Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 1998 Apr;157(4 Pt 1):1016-20. doi: 10.1164/ajrccm.157.4.9704036.
Despite the long-standing observation that tuberculosis (TB) case rates are higher among racial and ethnic minorities than whites in the United States (U.S.), the proportion of this increased risk attributable to socioeconomic status (SES) has not been determined. Values for six SES indicators (crowding, income, poverty, public assistance, unemployment, and education) were assigned to U.S. TB cases reported from 1987-1993 by ZIP code- and demographic-specific matching to 1990 U.S. Census data. TB risk between racial/ethnic groups was then evaluated by quartile for each SES indicator utilizing univariate and Poisson multivariate analyses. Relative risk (RR) of TB increased with lower SES quartile for all six SES indicators on univariate analysis (RRs 2.6-5.6 in the lowest versus highest quartiles). The same trend was observed in multivariate models containing individual SES indicators (RRs 1.8-2.5) and for three SES indicators (crowding, poverty, and education) in the model containing all six indicators. Tuberculosis risk increased uniformly between SES quartile for each indicator except crowding, where risk was concentrated in the lowest quartile. Adjusting for SES accounted for approximately half of the increased risk of TB associated with race/ethnicity among U.S.-born blacks, Hispanics, and Native Americans. Even more of this increased risk was accounted for in the final model, which also adjusted for interaction between crowding and race/ethnicity. SES impacts TB incidence via both a strong direct effect of crowding, manifested predominantly in overcrowded settings, and a TB-SES health gradient, manifested at all SES levels. SES accounts for much of the increased risk of TB previously associated with race/ethnicity.
尽管长期以来的观察表明,在美国,少数族裔的结核病发病率高于白人,但尚未确定社会经济地位(SES)导致这种风险增加的比例。通过将邮政编码和特定人口统计学数据与1990年美国人口普查数据进行匹配,为1987年至1993年报告的美国结核病病例分配了六个SES指标(拥挤程度、收入、贫困、公共援助、失业率和教育程度)的值。然后,利用单变量和泊松多变量分析,按每个SES指标的四分位数评估种族/族裔群体之间的结核病风险。单变量分析显示,所有六个SES指标的结核病相对风险(RR)均随着SES四分位数的降低而增加(最低四分位数与最高四分位数的RR为2.6至5.6)。在包含单个SES指标的多变量模型(RR为1.8至2.5)以及包含所有六个指标的模型中的三个SES指标(拥挤程度、贫困和教育程度)中也观察到了相同的趋势。除拥挤程度外,每个指标的结核病风险在SES四分位数之间均匀增加,而拥挤程度的风险集中在最低四分位数。调整SES后,在美国出生的黑人、西班牙裔和美洲原住民中,与种族/族裔相关的结核病风险增加约一半得到了解释。在最终模型中,这种增加的风险得到了更多解释,该模型还调整了拥挤程度与种族/族裔之间的相互作用。SES通过拥挤程度的强烈直接影响(主要表现在过度拥挤的环境中)和SES健康梯度(在所有SES水平上都有体现)影响结核病发病率。SES解释了以前与种族/族裔相关的结核病风险增加的大部分原因。