Shaver E G, Harvey A S, Morrison G, Prats A, Jayakar P, Dean P, Duchowny M
Comprehensive Epilepsy Center, Miami Children's Hospital, Department of Neurology, Fla, USA.
Pediatr Neurosurg. 1997 Oct;27(4):194-202. doi: 10.1159/000121251.
The seizure outcome and neurological outcome in children who undergo reoperation for failed epilepsy surgery have not been well documented. This retrospective study evaluated 20 children who underwent a second resective surgery for recurrent seizures. Four categories of patients were identified: (1) extension of the initial resection was performed in 8 patients; (2) 5 patients underwent lobectomy or corticectomy in a region remote from the original surgical site; (3) multilobar resection which may have included further resection of the initial procedure was accomplished in 4 patients; (4) hemispherectomy was performed in 3 patients. Patients with reoperation in the same lobe as the first procedure (group 1) had a 62% seizure-free rate, while 44% of patients in groups 2 and 3 were free from seizures at follow-up evaluation. Patients undergoing hemispherectomy had a 67% seizure-free rate. Significant unexpected neurological deficits occurred in 3 patients who underwent multilobar resection at reoperation. Complications included motor and language deficits. Reoperation for intractable partial epilepsy is beneficial in selected children. Patients who require multilobar resections may have higher risk of postoperative neurological deficit than those patients with reoperation in one lobe. These factors may be useful in counseling parents of children considering reoperation for recurrent epilepsy.
癫痫手术失败后接受再次手术的儿童的癫痫发作结果和神经学结果尚未得到充分记录。这项回顾性研究评估了20例因复发性癫痫发作而接受二次切除手术的儿童。确定了四类患者:(1)8例患者进行了初始切除范围的扩大;(2)5例患者在远离原手术部位的区域进行了叶切除术或皮质切除术;(3)4例患者完成了多叶切除术,其中可能包括对初始手术的进一步切除;(4)3例患者进行了大脑半球切除术。与首次手术在同一叶进行再次手术的患者(第1组)的无癫痫发作率为62%,而第2组和第3组的患者在随访评估时有44%无癫痫发作。接受大脑半球切除术的患者无癫痫发作率为67%。3例在再次手术时进行多叶切除术的患者出现了严重的意外神经功能缺损。并发症包括运动和语言缺陷。对难治性部分性癫痫进行再次手术对部分儿童有益。需要进行多叶切除术的患者术后出现神经功能缺损的风险可能高于在一个叶进行再次手术的患者。这些因素可能有助于为考虑对复发性癫痫进行再次手术的儿童的家长提供咨询。