Garaizar C, Prats J M, Zuazo E
Departamento de Pediatría, Hospital de Cruces, Barakaldo, Vizcaya, España.
Rev Neurol. 1998 Mar;26(151):380-5.
Common childhood headaches seldom require prophylactic treatment which, nevertheless, is quite often unsatisfactory.
To study drug and non-drug related factors that may influence the therapeutic response.
A four-month follow-up study of all patients attended during a year at the neuropediatric, outpatient hospital-based clinic, with > or = 2 monthly migraine without aura attacks, > or = 10 tension-type headaches, or both types of headaches. Patients were randomized to be treated on an open basis, placebo controlled, with flunarizine or piracetam. Headache frequency was evaluated according to treatment and patients' basal characteristics.
98 patients studied (56 migraine without aura, 24 tension-type headache, 18 mixed). 33% dropped out; they were school underachievers more frequently than those that completed the protocol. Of those completing the protocol and treated with placebo as the first choice of therapy, 27% reported total remission of symptomatology; those not remitting with placebo were high achievers at school significatively more frequently. At the end of the trial, 43% of the initially randomized patients still complained of headaches, regardless of treatment, showing a seasonal relationship.
Prophylaxis of benign childhood headaches is needed in less than half of those reporting a high headache frequency; school achievement should be taken into consideration as another clue to compliance and headache persistence. On a short-term basis only the seasonal influence and the placebo effect can be held responsible for amelioration of symptomatology.
常见的儿童头痛很少需要预防性治疗,然而,这种治疗往往不尽人意。
研究可能影响治疗反应的药物和非药物相关因素。
对一家基于门诊医院的神经儿科诊所一年中接诊的所有患者进行为期四个月的随访研究,这些患者每月有≥2次无先兆偏头痛发作、≥10次紧张型头痛发作或两种类型的头痛都有。患者被随机分为开放治疗组,采用安慰剂对照,使用氟桂利嗪或吡拉西坦。根据治疗情况和患者的基础特征评估头痛频率。
共研究了98例患者(56例无先兆偏头痛、24例紧张型头痛、18例混合型)。33%的患者退出研究;他们学业成绩不佳的频率高于完成研究方案的患者。在完成研究方案并以安慰剂作为首选治疗方法的患者中,27%报告症状完全缓解;未从安慰剂治疗中缓解的患者学业成绩优秀的频率明显更高。在试验结束时,无论接受何种治疗,最初随机分组的患者中有43%仍抱怨头痛,且呈现出季节性关系。
在报告头痛频率较高的儿童中,不到一半的人需要进行良性儿童头痛的预防性治疗;学业成绩应被视为依从性和头痛持续存在的另一个线索。短期内,只有季节性影响和安慰剂效应可被认为是症状改善的原因。