Moskal J T, Diduch D R
Roanoke Orthopaedic Center, Virginia 24018-0546, USA.
Am J Knee Surg. 1998 Spring;11(2):89-93.
We reviewed a single surgeon's experience with 646 consecutive total knee arthroplasties (TKAs) performed over a 6-year period to determine whether routine in-hospital radiographs could be safely avoided. Five hundred fourteen patients underwent 589 primary and 57 revision TKAs. One hundred thirty-two patients had bilateral procedures. Radiographs were obtained during the index hospitalization for 12 (2%) knees and were ordered selectively to assess femoral notching > or =3 mm, concomitant osteotomy, bulk allograft reconstruction, stem extension relative to existing hardware or screw holes, or falls during the index hospitalization. Radiographs were delayed until the initial postoperative office visit for the remaining 634 (98%) knees. Six hundred seventeen of 646 knees (96%) were evaluated at a mean follow-up of 4.3 years (range: 2 to 8 years). No patient experienced any complication that was considered to be attributable to not obtaining earlier postoperative radiographs. Three patients experienced late fractures and 7 patients developed perioperative soft-tissue complications or infections. None of these cases were adversely affected by delaying the initial postoperative radiographs. Eliminating in-hospital radiographs with radiologist interpretation resulted in a potential savings of $246 in hospital charges, $198 in private insurance reimbursements, and $65 in hospital costs per TKA. These findings indicate that radiographs following TKA can be delayed in most cases until the first postoperative office visit without compromising patient care.
我们回顾了一位外科医生在6年期间连续进行的646例全膝关节置换术(TKA)的经验,以确定是否可以安全地避免常规的住院期间X线检查。514例患者接受了589例初次和57例翻修TKA。132例患者进行了双侧手术。在初次住院期间,对12例(2%)膝关节进行了X线检查,并根据需要进行选择性检查,以评估股骨切迹≥3mm、同期截骨、大块同种异体骨重建、相对于现有硬件或螺钉孔的柄部延长情况,或初次住院期间的跌倒情况。其余634例(98%)膝关节的X线检查推迟到术后初次门诊就诊时进行。646例膝关节中的617例(96%)在平均随访4.3年(范围:2至8年)时接受了评估。没有患者出现任何被认为可归因于未早期进行术后X线检查的并发症。3例患者发生晚期骨折,7例患者出现围手术期软组织并发症或感染。这些病例均未因推迟术后初次X线检查而受到不利影响。取消由放射科医生解读的住院期间X线检查,每例TKA可节省潜在的医院费用246美元、私人保险报销费用198美元和医院成本65美元。这些发现表明,在大多数情况下,TKA术后的X线检查可以推迟到术后初次门诊就诊时进行,而不会影响患者护理。