Durrieu F, Belloc F, Lacoste L, Dumain P, Chabrol J, Dachary-Prigent J, Morjani H, Boisseau M R, Reiffers J, Bernard P, Lacombe F
Laboratoire d'Hématologie, Hôpital Haut Lévêque, Pessac, France.
Exp Cell Res. 1998 May 1;240(2):165-75. doi: 10.1006/excr.1997.3918.
An increasing number of methods are being described to detect apoptotic cells. However, attempts to detect apoptotic cells in clinical samples are rarely successful. A hypothesis is that apoptotic cells are cleared from the circulation by phagocytosis before they become detectable by conventional morphological or cytometric methods. Using LR73 adhering cells as phagocytes in a model of in vitro phagocytosis, we found that phagocytosis of daunorubicin (DNR)-treated U937, HL60, or K562 leukemia cell lines occurred prior to phosphatidylserine externalization, DNA hydrolysis, chromatin condensation, nuclear fragmentation, or mitochondrial potential alteration. Moreover DNR-treated K562 cells were eliminated by phagocytes while apoptosis was never observed by any of the above methods. By contrast, using a fluorometric batch analysis assay to detect caspase activity in ceramide- or DNR-treated cells (fluorogenic substrate for caspase), we found that caspase activity increased in apoptosis-committed cells before they were detected by flow cytometry or recognized by phagocytes. Similarly a caspase activity increase was detected in circulating mononuclear cells of luekemic patients 15 h after the beginning of anthracyclin treatment. We suggest that recent findings on enzymatic events (caspase activation) occurring in the early events of apoptosis must now allow the development of new markers for apoptosis, irrespective of the morphological features or internucleosomal fragmentation which are late events in apoptosis.
越来越多检测凋亡细胞的方法被报道。然而,在临床样本中检测凋亡细胞的尝试很少成功。一种假说认为,凋亡细胞在通过传统形态学或细胞计数方法可检测到之前就已被吞噬作用从循环中清除。在体外吞噬模型中使用LR73贴壁细胞作为吞噬细胞,我们发现柔红霉素(DNR)处理的U937、HL60或K562白血病细胞系在磷脂酰丝氨酸外化、DNA水解、染色质浓缩、核碎裂或线粒体膜电位改变之前就发生了吞噬作用。此外,吞噬细胞消除了DNR处理的K562细胞,而上述任何方法均未观察到凋亡现象。相比之下,使用荧光批量分析测定法检测神经酰胺或DNR处理的细胞中的半胱天冬酶活性(半胱天冬酶的荧光底物),我们发现凋亡细胞在通过流式细胞术检测到或被吞噬细胞识别之前,其半胱天冬酶活性就已增加。同样,在蒽环类药物治疗开始15小时后,白血病患者的循环单核细胞中检测到半胱天冬酶活性增加。我们认为,关于凋亡早期发生的酶促事件(半胱天冬酶激活)的最新发现现在必须能够促进新的凋亡标志物的开发,而不考虑凋亡后期出现的形态学特征或核小体间断裂。