Butterworth S A, Koppert E, Clarke A, Wiggs B, MacFarlane J K
Department of Surgery, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada.
Am J Surg. 1998 May;175(5):403-7. doi: 10.1016/S0002-9610(98)00058-0.
With the prevalence of antibiotic use, the diagnosis and management of Clostridium difficile disease requires assessment.
In a retrospective review, patients with a positive culture, toxin, or both during 1 year were identified. Recent literature was reviewed. Results of culture and toxin, prior antibiotic use, antibiotic treatment history and cost were analyzed.
Of 592 patients tested, 101 were positive; 96 of 101 were available for review. Of those positive tested for both, 45% were positive for toxin and culture. Sixty-two of 96 were treated with antibiotics; metronidazole was used in 90%. Ten of 62 antibiotic treatments were changed (mean 3 days). Ten days of metronidazole is 1/200th the cost of vancomycin.
In 55% of the positive cases in which culture and toxin were obtained, one test was negative. As metronidazole's efficacy and cost compares favorably with vancomycin, metronidazole is the drug of choice. Any changes made to antibiotic regimens occurred prior to the 6 days recommended in the literature.
随着抗生素使用的普及,艰难梭菌病的诊断和管理需要进行评估。
在一项回顾性研究中,确定了一年内培养结果、毒素检测结果或两者均为阳性的患者。对近期文献进行了综述。分析了培养和毒素检测结果、既往抗生素使用情况、抗生素治疗史及费用。
在592例接受检测的患者中,101例呈阳性;其中96例可进行评估。在同时进行两种检测均呈阳性的患者中,45%的患者毒素检测和培养结果均为阳性。96例患者中有62例接受了抗生素治疗;90%使用的是甲硝唑。62例接受抗生素治疗的患者中有10例更换了治疗药物(平均3天)。甲硝唑治疗10天的费用是万古霉素的1/200。
在同时进行培养和毒素检测且结果呈阳性的病例中,55%的患者一项检测结果为阴性。由于甲硝唑的疗效和费用优于万古霉素,因此甲硝唑是首选药物。抗生素治疗方案的任何更改均发生在文献推荐的6天之前。