Charbonnier B A, Fiessinger J N, Banga J D, Wenzel E, d'Azemar P, Sagnard L
University Hospital Trousseau, Tours, France.
Thromb Haemost. 1998 May;79(5):897-901.
Clinical trials have been performed to compare with standard heparin a once or a twice daily regimen of low-molecular-weight heparin but no direct comparison has been done between these two low-molecular-weight heparin regimens in terms of efficacy and safety with a long-term clinical evaluation.
Patients with proximal deep vein thrombosis, confirmed by venography were randomly assigned to either nadroparin (10,250 AXa IU/ml) twice daily or nadroparin (20,500 AXa IU/ml) once daily for at least 5 days. Regimens were adjusted to bodyweight. Oral anticoagulants were started on day 1 or 2 and continued for 3 months. Patients were followed up for 3 months. The composite outcome of venous thromboembolism and death possibly related to pulmonary embolism was the primary measure of efficacy. Major bleeding was the principal measure of safety. The study was designed to show equivalence between the two regimens.
Recurrent thromboembolic events or death possibly related to pulmonary embolism were reported in 13 patients in the once daily group (4.1%) and in 24 patients of the twice daily group (7.2%): (absolute difference 3.1% in favor of the once daily regimen; 95% confidence interval -6.6%, +0.5%). Major bleeding episodes during nadroparin treatment occurred in 4 (1.3%) and 4 patients (1.2%) in the once and twice daily groups, respectively.
A nadroparin regimen of one injection per day is at least as effective and safe as the same total daily dose divided over two injections for the treatment of acute deep vein thrombosis.
已开展临床试验,将低分子量肝素每日一次或两次给药方案与标准肝素进行比较,但尚未对这两种低分子量肝素给药方案在疗效和安全性方面进行长期临床评估的直接比较。
经静脉造影确诊为近端深静脉血栓形成的患者被随机分配接受那屈肝素(10,250抗Xa国际单位/毫升)每日两次或那屈肝素(20,500抗Xa国际单位/毫升)每日一次治疗,至少持续5天。给药方案根据体重进行调整。口服抗凝剂在第1天或第2天开始使用,并持续3个月。对患者进行3个月的随访。静脉血栓栓塞和可能与肺栓塞相关的死亡的复合结局是疗效的主要衡量指标。大出血是安全性的主要衡量指标。该研究旨在显示两种给药方案之间的等效性。
每日一次给药组有13例患者(4.1%)报告了复发性血栓栓塞事件或可能与肺栓塞相关的死亡,每日两次给药组有24例患者(7.2%)报告了此类情况:(绝对差异为3.1%,有利于每日一次给药方案;95%置信区间为-6.6%,+0.5%)。那屈肝素治疗期间,每日一次给药组和每日两次给药组分别有4例(1.3%)和4例(1.2%)患者发生大出血事件。
对于急性深静脉血栓形成的治疗,那屈肝素每日一次给药方案至少与将相同总日剂量分两次注射给药一样有效和安全。