Cutuli B, Dhermain F, Borel C, de Larochefordiere A, Graic Y, de Lafontan B, Dilhyudy J M, Mignotte H, Tessier E, Tortochaux J, N'Guyen T, Bey P, Le Mevel-Le Pourhiet A, Velten M, Arriagada R
Centre Paul Strauss, Department of Radiotherapy, Strasbourg, France.
Eur J Cancer. 1997 Dec;33(14):2315-20. doi: 10.1016/s0959-8049(97)00235-9.
In a retrospective multicentric analysis, 63 women treated between 1941 to 1988 for Hodgkin's disease (HD) subsequently developed 76 breast cancers (BC). The median age at diagnosis of HD was 26 years (range 7-67), and 22 women (35%) were 20 years old or less. Exclusive radiotherapy (RT) was used in 36 women (57%) and combined modalities with chemotherapy (CT) in 25 (39%). Breast cancer occurred after a median interval of 16 years (range 2-40) and the median age at diagnosis of the first BC was 42 years (range 25-73). TNM classification (UICC, 1978) showed 10 T0 (non-palpable lesions) (13%), 20 T1 (26%), 22 T2 (29%), 8 T3 (11%), 7 T4 (9%) and 9 Tx (12%), giving altogether a total of 76 tumours, including, respectively, 5 and 8 bilateral synchronous and metachronous lesions. Among the 68 tumours initially discovered, 53 ductal infiltrating, one lobular infiltrating and two medullary carcinomas were found. Moreover, two fibrosarcomas and 10 ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS) were also found. Among 50 axillary dissections for invasive carcinomas, histological involvement was found in 31 cases (62%). 45 tumours were treated by mastectomy, without (n = 35) or with (n = 10) RT. 27 tumours had lumpectomy, without (n = 7) or with RT (n = 20). 2 others received RT only, and one only CT. 7 patients (11%) developed isolated local recurrence. 20 patients (32%) developed metastases and all died; 38 are in complete remission, whereas 5 died of intercurrent disease. The 5-year disease-specific survival rate by the Kaplan-Meier method was 61%. The 5-year disease-specific survival rate for pN0, pN1-3 and pN > or = 3 groups were 91%, 66% and 0%, respectively (P < 0.0001) and 100%, 88%, 64% and 23% for the T0, T1, T2 and T3T4 groups, respectively. These secondary BCs seem to be of two types: a large number of aggressive tumours with a very unfavourable prognosis (especially in the case of pN > 3 and/or T3T4); and many tumours with a 'slow development' such as DCIS and microinvasive lesions, especially in patients treated exclusively by RT. Moreover, a very unusual rate of bilateral tumours (21%) was observed. These secondary BC could be 'in field', in 'border of field' or 'out of field'. However, a complete analysis of doses delivered by supradiaphragmatic irradiation was often very difficult, due to large variations in several parameters. We conclude that young women and girls treated for HD should be carefully monitored by clinical examination, mammography and ultrasonography.
在一项回顾性多中心分析中,1941年至1988年间接受治疗的63例霍奇金淋巴瘤(HD)女性患者随后发生了76例乳腺癌(BC)。HD诊断时的中位年龄为26岁(范围7 - 67岁),22例女性(35%)年龄在20岁及以下。36例女性(57%)仅接受了放射治疗(RT),25例(39%)采用了放疗联合化疗(CT)的综合治疗方式。乳腺癌发生的中位间隔时间为16年(范围2 - 40年),首例BC诊断时的中位年龄为42岁(范围25 - 73岁)。TNM分类(UICC,1978)显示10例T0(不可触及病变)(13%),20例T1(26%),22例T2(29%),8例T3(11%),7例T4(9%)和9例Tx(12%),共计76个肿瘤,其中分别有5例和8例双侧同步及异时性病变。在最初发现的68个肿瘤中,有53例导管浸润癌、1例小叶浸润癌和2例髓样癌。此外,还发现了2例纤维肉瘤和10例导管原位癌(DCIS)。在50例针对浸润性癌的腋窝清扫术中,31例(62%)发现有组织学受累。45个肿瘤接受了乳房切除术,其中35例未接受放疗,10例接受了放疗。27个肿瘤接受了肿块切除术,其中7例未接受放疗,20例接受了放疗。另外2例仅接受了放疗,1例仅接受了化疗。7例患者(11%)发生了孤立性局部复发。20例患者(32%)发生了转移并全部死亡;38例处于完全缓解状态,5例死于并发疾病。采用Kaplan - Meier方法计算的5年疾病特异性生存率为61%。pN0、pN1 - 3和pN≥3组的5年疾病特异性生存率分别为91%、66%和0%(P < 0.0001),T0、T1、T2和T3T4组分别为100%、88%、64%和23%。这些继发性BC似乎有两种类型:大量侵袭性肿瘤,预后非常不利(特别是在pN > 3和/或T3T4的情况下);以及许多“发展缓慢”的肿瘤,如DCIS和微浸润性病变,特别是在仅接受RT治疗的患者中。此外,观察到双侧肿瘤的发生率非常不寻常(21%)。这些继发性BC可能是“野内”、“野边缘”或“野外”的。然而,由于几个参数的巨大差异,对上膈照射剂量进行完整分析往往非常困难。我们得出结论,应对接受HD治疗的年轻女性和女孩进行临床检查、乳腺X线摄影和超声检查的仔细监测。