Vianna A, Piccelli H
Hospital Universitário de Brasília.
Rev Assoc Med Bras (1992). 1998 Jan-Mar;44(1):21-7. doi: 10.1590/s0104-42301998000100005.
The aim of this investigation was to study the feelings and attitudes of medical students, medical doctors and teachers of medicine facing death and terminal patients.
An inquiry about death and terminal patient was applied to 81 pre-clinical students, 139 clinical students, 52 medical doctors and 54 teachers of the Faculty of Health Sciences.
303 responders showed interest in this subject (93%); 179 had problems in dealing with it (55%). Only 136 searched for information (41.7%) and 116 have difficulty in finding it (85.1%). Non-especialized sources of information were the most used ones (61.1%). Twenty medical doctors (38%) and 13 teachers (24%) discussed the subject more often with patients, 47 pre-clinical students (58%) did it with friends and 40 with relatives (49.4%); 36 teachers did it with health professionals (66.6%). 263 responders rarely think about their own death (80.7%), and 38 do it constantly (11.6%); 157 are afraid of thinking about their own death (52.2%). Eleven pre-clinical students (13.8%), ten clinical students (7.2%) and 4 medical doctors (7.4%) never thought of their own death. Before entering medical school, 136 responders had some kind of contact with corpses (41.8%). The interest about death did not change, after dealing with corpses in anatomy classes, to 321 responders (98.5%), the same happening with 236 individuals (96.3%) after necroscopy. During the clinical year 111 students (79.9%) worked with terminal patients.
The authors suggest that formal education about death and terminal patient in medical schools, starting early in the medical course, as well as permanent attention to the theme by professionals, could modify the attitudes of students and medical doctors toward a better way in dealing with this subject.
本调查旨在研究医学生、医生和医学教师面对死亡和晚期患者时的感受与态度。
对健康科学学院的81名临床前学生、139名临床学生、52名医生和54名教师进行了关于死亡和晚期患者的问卷调查。
303名受访者对该主题感兴趣(93%);179人在处理该主题时存在问题(55%)。只有136人寻找过信息(41.7%),其中116人在获取信息方面存在困难(85.1%)。最常使用的是非专业信息来源(61.1%)。20名医生(38%)和13名教师(24%)更常与患者讨论该主题,47名临床前学生(58%)与朋友讨论,40名与亲属讨论(49.4%);36名教师与健康专业人员讨论(66.6%)。263名受访者很少思考自己的死亡(80.7%),38人经常思考(11.6%);157人害怕思考自己的死亡(52.2%)。11名临床前学生(13.8%)、10名临床学生(7.2%)和4名医生(7.4%)从未思考过自己的死亡。在进入医学院之前,136名受访者曾接触过尸体(41.8%)。在解剖课上接触尸体后,321名受访者(98.5%)对死亡的兴趣未变,尸检后236人(96.3%)也是如此。在临床实习期间,111名学生(79.9%)接触过晚期患者。
作者建议,医学院校应在医学课程早期开始进行关于死亡和晚期患者的正规教育,同时专业人员应持续关注该主题,这可能会改善学生和医生应对该主题的态度,使其方式更加恰当。