Dehlendorf C E, Wolfe S M
Public Citizen's Health Research Group, Washington, DC 20009, USA.
JAMA. 1998 Jun 17;279(23):1883-8. doi: 10.1001/jama.279.23.1883.
Physicians who abuse their patients sexually cause immense harm, and, therefore, the discipline of physicians who commit any sex-related offenses is an important public health issue that should be examined.
To determine the frequency and severity of discipline against physicians who commit sex-related offenses and to describe the characteristics of these physicians.
Analysis of sex-related orders from a national database of disciplinary orders taken by state medical boards and federal agencies.
A total of 761 physicians disciplined for sex-related offenses from 1981 through 1996.
Rate and severity of discipline over time for sex-related offenses and specialty, age, and board certification status of disciplined physicians.
The number of physicians disciplined per year for sex-related offenses increased from 42 in 1989 to 147 in 1996, and the proportion of all disciplinary orders that were sex related increased from 2.1% in 1989 to 4.4% in 1996 (P<.001 for trend). Discipline for sex-related offenses was significantly more severe (P<.001) than for non-sex-related offenses, with 71.9% of sex-related orders involving revocation, surrender, or suspension of medical license. Of 761 physicians disciplined, the offenses committed by 567 (75%) involved patients, including sexual intercourse, rape, sexual molestation, and sexual favors for drugs. As of March 1997, 216 physicians (39.9%) disciplined for sex-related offenses between 1981 and 1994 were licensed to practice. Compared with all physicians, physicians disciplined for sex-related offenses were more likely to practice in the specialties of psychiatry, child psychiatry, obstetrics and gynecology, and family and general practice (all P<.001) than in other specialties and were older than the national physician population, but were no different in terms of board certification status.
Discipline against physicians for sex-related offenses is increasing over time and is relatively severe, although few physicians are disciplined for sexual offenses each year. In addition, a substantial proportion of physicians disciplined for these offenses are allowed to either continue to practice or return to practice.
对患者实施性侵犯的医生会造成极大伤害,因此,对犯有任何与性相关罪行的医生进行惩戒是一个重要的公共卫生问题,应予以审视。
确定对犯有与性相关罪行的医生进行惩戒的频率和严厉程度,并描述这些医生的特征。
对州医学委员会和联邦机构采取的全国性纪律处分命令数据库中的与性相关命令进行分析。
1981年至1996年期间因与性相关罪行而受到惩戒的761名医生。
与性相关罪行的惩戒率和严厉程度随时间的变化,以及受惩戒医生的专业、年龄和委员会认证状态。
每年因与性相关罪行而受到惩戒的医生人数从1989年的42人增加到1996年的147人,所有纪律处分命令中与性相关的比例从1989年的2.1%增加到1996年的4.4%(趋势P<0.001)。与性相关罪行的惩戒明显比非性相关罪行更严厉(P<0.001),71.9%的与性相关命令涉及吊销、交出或暂停医生执照。在761名受惩戒的医生中,567名(75%)的罪行涉及患者,包括性交、强奸、性骚扰以及以提供性服务换取毒品。截至1997年3月,1981年至1994年期间因与性相关罪行而受到惩戒的216名医生(39.9%)仍持有行医执照。与所有医生相比,因与性相关罪行而受到惩戒的医生在精神病学、儿童精神病学、妇产科以及家庭和普通科专业执业的可能性更高(均P<0.001),年龄也比全国医生群体更大,但在委员会认证状态方面没有差异。
对医生与性相关罪行的惩戒随时间增加且相对严厉,尽管每年因性犯罪而受到惩戒的医生较少。此外,相当一部分因这些罪行而受到惩戒的医生被允许继续行医或恢复行医。