Türp J C, Kowalski C J, O'Leary N, Stohler C S
Department of Biologic and Materials Sciences, School of Dentistry, The University of Michigan, Ann Arbor 48109-1078, USA.
J Dent Res. 1998 Jun;77(6):1465-72. doi: 10.1177/00220345980770061101.
Two hundred consecutive female patients, who were referred to a university-based facial pain clinic, were asked to mark all painful sites on sketches showing the contours of a human body in the frontal and rear views. The drawings were analyzed with transparent templates containing 1875 (frontal view) and 1929 (rear view) square cells of equal size. The average patient scored 71.8 cells in the frontal and 99.7 cells in the rear view (corresponding to 3.8% and 5.2% of the maximum possible scores). In individual patient drawings, however, up to 42.7% and 44.9% of all cells were marked. Only 37 cases (18.5%) exhibited pain that was limited to the trigeminal system. An analysis of the pain distribution according to the arrangements of dermatomes revealed three distinct clusters of patients: (1) pain restricted to the region innervated by the trigeminal nerves (n = 37); (2) pain in the trigeminal dermatomes and any combination involving the spinal dermatomes C2, C3, and C4, but no other dermatomes (n = 32); and (3) pain sites involving dermatomes in addition to the ones listed above (n = 131). Mean ages in the three clusters were 38.7, 35.5, and 37.5 years, respectively (p = 0.62, n.s.). Widespread pain existed for longer durations (median, 48 months) than conditions involving local and regional pain (median, 24 months) (p = 0.02, s.). Our findings showed that among a great percentage of persistent facial pain patients the pain distribution is more widespread than commonly assumed, and that the persistence of pain in the regional and widespread pain presentations is significantly greater than in cases with pain limited to the trigeminal system.
连续200名转诊至某大学面部疼痛诊所的女性患者,被要求在展示人体正面和背面轮廓的草图上标记出所有疼痛部位。使用包含1875个(正面视图)和1929个(背面视图)大小相等的方形单元格的透明模板对这些绘图进行分析。平均每位患者在正面视图中标出71.8个单元格,在背面视图中标出99.7个单元格(分别对应最大可能分数的3.8%和5.2%)。然而,在个别患者的绘图中,标记的单元格多达所有单元格的42.7%和44.9%。只有37例(18.5%)表现出仅限于三叉神经系统的疼痛。根据皮节分布对疼痛进行分析,发现了三组不同的患者:(1)疼痛局限于三叉神经支配区域(n = 37);(2)三叉神经皮节疼痛以及涉及颈2、颈3和颈4脊髓皮节的任何组合,但不涉及其他皮节(n = 32);(3)除上述皮节外还涉及其他皮节的疼痛部位(n = 131)。三组的平均年龄分别为38.7岁、35.5岁和37.5岁(p = 0.62,无统计学意义)。广泛性疼痛存在的时间(中位数,48个月)比局部和区域性疼痛情况(中位数,24个月)更长(p = 0.02,有统计学意义)。我们的研究结果表明,在很大比例的持续性面部疼痛患者中,疼痛分布比通常认为的更广泛,并且区域性和广泛性疼痛表现中的疼痛持续性明显大于仅限于三叉神经系统疼痛的病例。