Pollner M
Department of Sociology, University of California, Los Angeles 90095-1551, USA.
J Nerv Ment Dis. 1998 Jun;186(6):369-73. doi: 10.1097/00005053-199806000-00008.
Despite indications that gender can affect the disclosure of personal information, few studies examine the effects of interviewer gender in eliciting information pertaining to psychological functioning and mental health. Analysis of data collected at the Los Angeles site of the Epidemiological Catchment Area Study reveals that interviewer gender is significantly related to respondents' reports of psychiatric symptoms. Male and female respondents interviewed by women report more symptoms of depression, substance abuse, and conduct disorders than respondents interviewed by men. It is suggested that female interviewers may create conditions more conducive to disclosure and be perceived as more sympathetic than male interviewers. Although limitations of both data and analysis preclude a definitive conclusion, the findings suggest that interviewer gender may influence disclosure in mental health and related types of interviews.
尽管有迹象表明性别会影响个人信息的披露,但很少有研究考察访谈者性别在引出与心理功能和心理健康相关信息方面的作用。对在洛杉矶地区进行的流行病学集水区研究收集的数据进行分析后发现,访谈者性别与受访者报告的精神症状显著相关。由女性访谈的男性和女性受访者比由男性访谈的受访者报告出更多的抑郁、药物滥用和行为障碍症状。研究表明,女性访谈者可能会创造出更有利于披露信息的条件,并且被认为比男性访谈者更具同情心。尽管数据和分析的局限性妨碍得出明确结论,但研究结果表明,访谈者性别可能会影响心理健康及相关类型访谈中的信息披露。