Evaluation of toxicity indicators in rat primary astrocytes, C6 glioma and human 1321N1 astrocytoma cells: can gliotoxicity be distinguished from cytotoxicity?

A comparison was made of rat primary astrocytes, C6 glioma cells pre-treated with dibutyryl cyclic AMP, and the human astrocyte 132N1 cell line using a range of 40 compounds and the neutral red (NR) assay. The 40 chemicals included substances known to be toxic to astrocytes or neurons, to be generally cytotoxic or not thought to be toxic to nervous tissue. For those compounds which were toxic, changes in glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP) levels were measured in the primary and C6 cultures, and changes in vimentin and S-100 measured in the C6 cells. The number of compounds with EC50 values < 2000 microg/ml for the NR assay for the different cell cultures were as follows: primary astrocytes, 19; C6 cells, 15; and 1321N1 cells, 11. The log of the EC50 values for the NR assay for the test compounds between the three cell types was not significantly different at the 5% level by paired Student's t-test. For the toxic substances the correlation coefficients of the EC50 values between primary cells and the C6 or 1321N1 cells were r > 0.5, and between the C6 and 1321N1 cells r > 0.9. For GFAP there was a similar degree of correlation in EC50 values between the different cell types. The GFAP, vimentin and S-100 levels showed similar EC50 values for the toxicants, but were not as sensitive as the NR assay. The toxic substances caused altered morphology in the primary, C6 and 1321N1 cells, with increased branching of cell processes. The combined astrocyte systems identified 8 out of 9 substances reported to be toxic to astrocytes in vivo, together with substances which have general cytotoxic properties. A number of substances (including the 1 out of 9 reported gliotoxic substances), which may primarily affect neurons, which may affect nervous tissue after long-term exposure, or which are not thought to be toxic to nervous tissue, were not detected. The astrocyte systems positively identify gliotoxic and cytotoxic substances and will allow detailed mechanistic studies to be made on the different underlying mechanisms.