Silber J H, Fridman M, DiPaola R S, Erder M H, Pauly M V, Fox K R
University of Pennsylvania Cancer Center and the Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics, Department of Pediatrics and Medicine, School of Medicine, Philadelphia, USA.
J Clin Oncol. 1998 Jul;16(7):2392-400. doi: 10.1200/JCO.1998.16.7.2392.
If patients could be ranked according to their projected need for supportive care therapy, then more efficient and less costly treatment algorithms might be developed. This work reports on the construction of a model of neutropenia, dose reduction, or delay that rank-orders patients according to their need for costly supportive care such as granulocyte growth factors.
A case series and consecutive sample of patients treated for breast cancer were studied. Patients had received standard-dose adjuvant chemotherapy for early-stage nonmetastatic breast cancer and were treated by four medical oncologists. Using 95 patients and validated with 80 additional patients, development models were constructed to predict one or more of the following events: neutropenia (absolute neutrophil count [ANC] < or = 250/microL), dose reduction > or = 15% of that scheduled, or treatment delay > or = 7 days. Two approaches to modeling were attempted. The pretreatment approach used only pretreatment predictors such as chemotherapy regimen and radiation history; the conditional approach included, in addition, blood count information obtained in the first cycle of treatment.
The pretreatment model was unsuccessful at predicting neutropenia, dose reduction, or delay (c-statistic = 0.63). Conditional models were good predictors of subsequent events after cycle 1 (c-statistic = 0.87 and 0.78 for development and validation samples, respectively). The depth of the first-cycle ANC was an excellent predictor of events in subsequent cycles (P = .0001 to .004). Chemotherapy plus radiation also increased the risk of subsequent events (P = .0011 to .0901). Decline in hemoglobin (HGB) level during the first cycle of therapy was a significant predictor of events in the development study (P = .0074 and .0015), and although the trend was similar in the validation study, HGB decline failed to reach statistical significance.
It is possible to rank patients according to their need of supportive care based on blood counts observed in the first cycle of therapy. Such rankings may aid in the choice of appropriate supportive care for patients with early-stage breast cancer.
如果能够根据患者对支持性护理治疗的预期需求对患者进行排序,那么或许可以制定出更高效且成本更低的治疗方案。本研究报告了一个关于中性粒细胞减少、剂量降低或治疗延迟的模型构建,该模型根据患者对粒细胞生长因子等昂贵支持性护理的需求对患者进行排序。
对一组接受乳腺癌治疗的病例系列患者及连续样本进行研究。这些患者接受了早期非转移性乳腺癌的标准剂量辅助化疗,由四位肿瘤内科医生进行治疗。利用95例患者构建开发模型,并通过另外80例患者进行验证,以预测以下一种或多种事件:中性粒细胞减少(绝对中性粒细胞计数[ANC]≤250/μL)、剂量降低≥预定剂量的15%或治疗延迟≥7天。尝试了两种建模方法。预处理方法仅使用化疗方案和放疗史等预处理预测因素;条件方法除了包括治疗第一周期获得的血细胞计数信息外,还包括其他因素。
预处理模型在预测中性粒细胞减少、剂量降低或治疗延迟方面未成功(c统计量 = 0.63)。条件模型是第1周期后后续事件的良好预测指标(开发样本和验证样本的c统计量分别为0.87和0.78)。第一周期ANC的深度是后续周期事件的极佳预测指标(P = 0.0001至0.004)。化疗加放疗也增加了后续事件的风险(P = 0.0011至0.0901)。治疗第一周期血红蛋白(HGB)水平下降是开发研究中事件的显著预测指标(P = 0.0074和0.0015),尽管在验证研究中趋势相似,但HGB下降未达到统计学显著性。
根据治疗第一周期观察到的血细胞计数,有可能根据患者对支持性护理的需求对患者进行排序。这样的排序可能有助于为早期乳腺癌患者选择合适的支持性护理。