Levi S, Montenegro N A
Obstetrics-Gynecology Diagnostic Ultrasound Unit, Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Brugmann, Brussels, Belgium.
Ann N Y Acad Sci. 1998 Jun 18;847:103-17. doi: 10.1111/j.1749-6632.1998.tb08931.x.
The aims of this study are (1) to evaluate the efficiency of ultrasound in detecting CA in low-risk populations of pregnant women by routine screening performed in hospital ultrasound labs (level II); (2) to highlight the areas where improvement could be obtained; (3) to determine efficient timing and number of examinations; (4) to evaluate the psychological returns of detection and nondetection of CA; and (5) to evaluate the cost-effectiveness ratio of antenatal screening of CA. A European collaboration was supposed to help in meeting these objectives because results concerning the analysis of individual CAs or groups of CAs can only be statistically significant when their number is sufficiently large. It was estimated that it was necessary to collect nearly 5,000 CA; this corresponds to about 200,000 pregnant women, the prevalence of malformations at birth being estimated at 2.5%. These conditions yield worthy conclusions, given the following circumstances: a large variety of CA, the extremely low incidence of each CA, the multiple approaches for diagnosis and management, the manifold classes of defects, the differences in gestational age when anomalies are detectable and detected. We study prospectively (1) the reliability of ultrasound in detecting antenatal malformations by recording all CA, ultrasonically suspected and not; (2) the gestational age of anomaly recognition; (3) the response to antenatal diagnosis of CA; (4) the individual outcome of pregnancies; (5) the financial cost of the screening program; and (6) the psychological consequences for the parents.
(1)通过医院超声实验室(二级)进行的常规筛查,评估超声在低风险孕妇群体中检测先天性异常(CA)的效率;(2)突出可改进的领域;(3)确定有效的检查时间和次数;(4)评估检测到和未检测到CA的心理回报;(5)评估CA产前筛查的成本效益比。一项欧洲合作本应有助于实现这些目标,因为只有当个体CA或CA组的分析结果数量足够大时,其统计结果才具有显著性。据估计,有必要收集近5000例CA;这相当于约20万名孕妇,出生时畸形的患病率估计为2.5%。考虑到以下情况,这些条件可得出有价值的结论:CA种类繁多、每种CA的发病率极低、诊断和管理方法多样、缺陷类别众多、可检测到异常和实际检测到异常时的孕周差异。我们前瞻性地研究:(1)通过记录所有CA(无论超声是否怀疑)来评估超声检测产前畸形的可靠性;(2)异常识别的孕周;(3)对CA产前诊断的反应;(4)妊娠的个体结局;(5)筛查项目的财务成本;(6)对父母的心理影响。