Duchowny M, Jayakar P, Resnick T, Harvey A S, Alvarez L, Dean P, Gilman J, Yaylali I, Morrison G, Prats A, Altman N, Birchansky S, Bruce J
Neuroscience Program and the Comprehensive Epilepsy Center, Miami Children's Hospital, Florida 33155, USA.
Epilepsia. 1998 Jul;39(7):737-43. doi: 10.1111/j.1528-1157.1998.tb01159.x.
Partial seizures in early postnatal life may be catastrophic and associated with poor long-term outcome. Epilepsy surgery can alleviate partial seizures in older children and adults, but there is little experience with surgical therapy in infancy apart from hemispheric epilepsy syndromes.
We analyzed the results of cortical resection to treat medically refractory partial epilepsy in 31 children (16 boys, 15 girls) aged <3 years (mean, 18.3 months). Subjects were included only if seizure relief was the primary indication for surgery.
Follow-up of at least 1 year (mean, 4.6 years) in 26 patients revealed that 16 were seizure-free, 4 had >90% seizure reduction, and 6 had <90% reduction. There was no significant difference in seizure outcome between hemispherectomy/multilobar resections and lobar resections or temporal versus extratemporal resection. Seizure outcome was independent of the amount of cortex removed in nonlesional patients. Only the presence of a discrete lesion on preoperative neuroimaging correlated with a favorable outcome. Family perceptions of accelerated development in seizure-free patients were not confirmed on developmental assessment.
We conclude that cortical resection often benefits very young children with catastrophic partial seizures, but does not guarantee enhanced neurological development. The location and extent of the excised cortex may not be critical as long as the entire epileptogenic region and lesion are removed.
出生后早期的部分性癫痫发作可能具有灾难性,并与不良的长期预后相关。癫痫手术可缓解大龄儿童和成人的部分性癫痫发作,但除半球性癫痫综合征外,婴儿期手术治疗的经验很少。
我们分析了31名年龄小于3岁(平均18.3个月)的儿童(16名男孩,15名女孩)接受皮质切除术治疗药物难治性部分性癫痫的结果。仅当癫痫缓解是手术的主要指征时才纳入研究对象。
26例患者至少随访1年(平均4.6年),结果显示16例无癫痫发作,4例癫痫发作减少>90%,6例癫痫发作减少<90%。半球切除术/多叶切除术与叶切除术之间,以及颞叶与颞外切除术之间,癫痫发作结局无显著差异。在无病变患者中,癫痫发作结局与切除的皮质量无关。只有术前神经影像学上存在离散病变与良好结局相关。无癫痫发作患者家属认为其发育加速,但发育评估未证实这一点。
我们得出结论,皮质切除术通常对患有灾难性部分性癫痫发作的幼儿有益,但不能保证神经发育得到改善。只要切除整个致痫区域和病变,切除皮质的位置和范围可能并不关键。