Rong F, Cui B
First People Hospital, Shun De Guang Dong Province, People's Republic of China.
Chest. 1998 Jul;114(1):36-9. doi: 10.1378/chest.114.1.36.
This study was performed to determine whether transbronchial needle aspiration (TBNA) biopsy under CT guidance can increase its diagnostic yield so that this technique can be used for staging of lung cancer at our institution.
After an initial unacceptable low yield of TBNA on the first 10 patients (20% positive), we switched the biopsy procedure from the bronchoscopy suite to the CT room. After each passage of the needle to the mediastinum lymph node, CT scan was performed to locate the tip of the needle. If the initial attempt was not successful, TBNA was repeated at the same setting until CT documented that the tip of the needle was exactly inside the lymph node.
A total of 49 patients with 69 mediastinum adenopathies were enrolled in this study. There were 31 patients with malignant mediastinal adenopathy proven by TBNA (60% sensitivity). Fifteen patients showed normal results of needle aspiration despite the presence of primary lung cancer. Three patients showed mediastinal abscesses.
Despite numerous successful reports in the literature, the general application of the TBNA procedure appears to be limited because of its low sensitivity, although this could be due to numerous factors. However, using CT guidance to be sure that the tip of the needle is exactly inside the node can increase its sensitivity markedly. It may also increase the specificity of normal results of TBNA biopsy.
本研究旨在确定CT引导下经支气管针吸活检(TBNA)能否提高其诊断率,以便该技术可用于本机构肺癌的分期。
在最初的10例患者中,TBNA的诊断率较低(阳性率为20%),之后我们将活检程序从支气管镜检查室转移至CT室。每次将针穿刺至纵隔淋巴结后,进行CT扫描以定位针尖位置。如果初次尝试未成功,则在相同条件下重复TBNA,直至CT显示针尖准确位于淋巴结内。
本研究共纳入49例有69处纵隔淋巴结肿大的患者。经TBNA证实有31例患者存在恶性纵隔淋巴结肿大(敏感性为60%)。15例患者尽管患有原发性肺癌,但针吸结果正常。3例患者出现纵隔脓肿。
尽管文献中有许多成功的报道,但由于其敏感性较低,TBNA程序的广泛应用似乎受到限制,不过这可能是由多种因素导致的。然而,使用CT引导以确保针尖准确位于淋巴结内可显著提高其敏感性。这也可能提高TBNA活检正常结果的特异性。