Opdal S H, Rognum T O, Vege A, Saugstad O D
Institute of Forensic Medicine, University of Oslo, The National Hospital, Norway.
Pediatr Res. 1998 Aug;44(2):192-6. doi: 10.1203/00006450-199808000-00009.
Elevated hypoxanthine (Hx) levels in the vitreous humor of victims of the sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) have been been claimed to indicate hypoxia before death. An important methodologic problem is the temperature-dependent Hx increase after death. Although most previous studies have corrected for expected postmortem Hx increase, the aim of the present study was to omit this problem by matching the subjects of the different groups studied for similar postmortem time. Thirteen cases of violent death, 11 cases of borderline SIDS, 22 cases of death from infectious disease, and 17 cases of death from heart/lung disease were compared with a 3-fold number of SIDS cases. To investigate the impact of environmental factors on the Hx levels of the SIDS cases, the following possible confounding factors were investigated: attempt to resuscitate, slight infections before death, sleeping position, and time of the day when found dead. To investigate whether the size of the eyeball would influence the Hx level, five cases of violent death in children were compared with 15 adults who died suddenly. The vitreous humor Hx level was significantly higher in SIDS victims than in cases of violent death (p < 0.01) and deaths due to heart/lung disease (p < 0.01), whereas no such difference was found either between SIDS and borderline SIDS or SIDS and infectious death. There were no differences between any of the subgroups of SIDS victims. The vitreous humor Hx level in small children and adults did not differ. The findings raise the question of possible similarities in death mechanism in SIDS and infectious death.
婴儿猝死综合征(SIDS)受害者玻璃体液中次黄嘌呤(Hx)水平升高被认为表明死前存在缺氧情况。一个重要的方法学问题是死后Hx水平随温度升高。尽管大多数先前的研究已对预期的死后Hx升高进行了校正,但本研究的目的是通过使不同研究组的受试者在死后时间相似来避免这个问题。将13例暴力死亡病例、11例边缘性SIDS病例、22例传染病死亡病例和17例心肺疾病死亡病例与三倍数量的SIDS病例进行比较。为了研究环境因素对SIDS病例Hx水平的影响,对以下可能的混杂因素进行了调查:复苏尝试、死前轻微感染、睡眠姿势以及发现死亡的时间。为了研究眼球大小是否会影响Hx水平,将5例儿童暴力死亡病例与15例突然死亡的成人病例进行比较。SIDS受害者的玻璃体液Hx水平显著高于暴力死亡病例(p < 0.01)和心肺疾病死亡病例(p < 0.01),而在SIDS与边缘性SIDS之间或SIDS与感染性死亡之间未发现此类差异。SIDS受害者的任何亚组之间均无差异。儿童和成人的玻璃体液Hx水平没有差异。这些发现提出了SIDS和感染性死亡在死亡机制上可能存在相似性的问题。