Brunner-La Rocca H P, Weilenmann D, Bracht C, Carli S, Schlumpf M, Follath F, Kiowski W
Division of Cardiology, University Hospital, Zurich, Switzerland.
J Heart Lung Transplant. 1998 Jul;17(7):725-8.
Although there is evidence of partial sympathetic reinnervation late after transplantation, little is known about the relative frequency of sympathetic and, in particular, parasympathetic reinnervation. We examined the heart rate response to various maneuvers (standing up, handgrip exercise, phase 2 of Valsalva maneuver for sympathetic function, carotid sinus massage, phase 4 of Valsalva maneuver, and atropine for parasympathetic function) in 65 patients 3 to 110 months after transplantation and in 16 healthy volunteers and defined reinnervation as either one normal (>50% of control group) and at least one partial (>33% of control group) heart rate response or partial responses in all three tests of the respective part of the autonomic nervous system. Thirty-five (54%) patients had sympathetic reinnervation, but only 16 (25%) had parasympathetic reinnervation (p < 0.001); earliest reinnervation was found 11 months after transplantation, and all but one patient with parasympathetic reinnervation also had sympathetic reinnervation. Signs of sympathetic but not parasympathetic reinnervation were common late (>5 years) after transplantation (74% vs 30%).
虽然有证据表明移植后晚期存在部分交感神经再支配,但对于交感神经尤其是副交感神经再支配的相对频率知之甚少。我们在65例移植后3至110个月的患者以及16名健康志愿者中,检测了他们对各种动作(站立、握力运动、用于检测交感神经功能的瓦尔萨尔瓦动作第二阶段、颈动脉窦按摩、瓦尔萨尔瓦动作第四阶段以及用于检测副交感神经功能的阿托品)的心率反应,并将再支配定义为自主神经系统相应部分的三项测试中,要么有一项正常(>对照组的50%)且至少有一项部分反应(>对照组的33%),要么三项测试均为部分反应。35例(54%)患者有交感神经再支配,但只有16例(25%)有副交感神经再支配(p<0.001);最早的再支配在移植后11个月发现,除1例副交感神经再支配患者外,其他所有患者也有交感神经再支配。移植后晚期(>5年)交感神经而非副交感神经再支配的体征很常见(74%对30%)。