Seidenari S, Pellacani G, Pepe P
Department of Dermatology, University of Modena, Italy.
J Am Acad Dermatol. 1998 Aug;39(2 Pt 1):175-81. doi: 10.1016/s0190-9622(98)70070-2.
To enhance the clinical evaluation of pigmented skin lesions (PSL), examination of PSL at a high magnification and computer-aided diagnosis have been introduced. Besides surface microscopes, "videomicroscopes" that are provided with polarized light are commercially available. Images recorded in the polarizing mode are comparable with those obtained after application of a drop of oil and a glass slide.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the usefulness of a digital videomicroscope equipped with a dedicated program for the diagnosis of melanocytic PSL by assessing the digital features referring to benign and malignant PSL images and by comparing the clinical assessment performed on 20-fold magnified images to computer diagnosis that were provided by the discriminant analysis calculation carried out on the numeric values describing the images.
Nine hundred seventeen melanocytic PSL images, corresponding to 852 nevi and 65 melanomas, were considered. For microscopic examination, a 10- (39 cases), 20-(501 cases), or 50-fold magnification (377 cases) was chosen according to the size of the lesion, enabling the whole lesion to be seen on the monitor. All digital images were framed and analyzed with software that calculates different features related to the geometry, color distribution, and internal pattern of the lesion. Features referring to benign and malignant PSL were compared. Moreover, 90 PSL images recorded by a x20 magnification, corresponding to 59 benign PSL and 31 malignant melanomas, were evaluated by 2 observers, 1 observer experienced in videomicroscopy and 1 observer, an untrained dermatologist. Sensitivity and specificity were estimated for observer assessment and computer diagnosis.
Significant differences between values referring to benign and malignant PSL were observed for most numeric features. Sensitivity was higher for the computer assessment and lower for the inexperienced observer, whereas specificity was the same for the computer and the trained observer.
Numeric features referring to benign PSL significantly differ from those of malignant PSL images. Elaboration of videomicroscopic images by means of a dedicated program improves diagnostic accuracy over the simple examination of pigmented skin lesions by means of magnifying and polarizing systems.
为加强对色素沉着性皮肤病变(PSL)的临床评估,已引入高倍放大检查PSL以及计算机辅助诊断。除了表面显微镜外,配备偏光的“视频显微镜”也已商业化。在偏光模式下记录的图像与滴一滴油并用载玻片获得的图像相当。
本研究的目的是通过评估参考良性和恶性PSL图像的数字特征,并将在20倍放大图像上进行的临床评估与通过对描述图像的数值进行判别分析计算得出的计算机诊断结果进行比较,来评估配备专用程序的数字视频显微镜对黑素细胞性PSL诊断的有用性。
共考虑了917张黑素细胞性PSL图像,对应852个痣和65个黑色素瘤。对于显微镜检查,根据病变大小选择10倍(39例)、20倍(501例)或50倍放大(377例),以便在监视器上看到整个病变。所有数字图像均用软件进行取景和分析,该软件可计算与病变的几何形状、颜色分布和内部模式相关的不同特征。比较了参考良性和恶性PSL的特征。此外,由2名观察者对90张以20倍放大率记录的PSL图像进行评估,这2名观察者分别为1名有视频显微镜经验的观察者和1名未经培训的皮肤科医生,这些图像对应59个良性PSL和31个恶性黑色素瘤。对观察者评估和计算机诊断的敏感性和特异性进行了估计。
大多数数值特征在参考良性和恶性PSL的值之间存在显著差异。计算机评估的敏感性较高,经验不足的观察者的敏感性较低,而计算机和经过培训的观察者的特异性相同。
参考良性PSL的数值特征与恶性PSL图像的数值特征有显著差异。通过专用程序对视频显微镜图像进行处理,比通过放大和偏光系统对色素沉着性皮肤病变进行简单检查能提高诊断准确性。