Tsuang M T, Dempsey M, Rauscher F
Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1976 Oct;33(10):11157-60.
Eighty-five cases of atypical schizophrenia were compared with 200 of schizophrenia, 100 of bipolar (mania), and 225 of unipolar (depression) affective disorder. Comparisons were made on the basis of sex, age at admission, precipitating factors, outcome, and a family history of schizophrenia or of affective disorder. The atypical schizophrenia differed remarkably from the schizophrenia and most closely resembled the bipolar affective disorder when allowance was made for a younger age at onset and a higher frequency of precipitants. An analysis of symptoms verified the predominance of schizophrenic features in the atypical schizophrenia, but also showed a high percentage (80%) of patients who had one or more manic symptoms at index admission. It is concluded that great care should be taken in diagnosing schizophrenia in a patient who also has manic symptoms.
将85例非典型精神分裂症患者与200例精神分裂症患者、100例双相(躁狂)情感障碍患者以及225例单相(抑郁)情感障碍患者进行了比较。比较基于性别、入院年龄、诱发因素、预后以及精神分裂症或情感障碍的家族史。当考虑到发病年龄较小和诱发因素出现频率较高时,非典型精神分裂症与精神分裂症有显著差异,且与双相情感障碍最为相似。症状分析证实非典型精神分裂症中精神分裂症特征占主导,但也显示有80%的患者在首次入院时有一个或多个躁狂症状。结论是,对于同时有躁狂症状的患者,在诊断精神分裂症时应格外谨慎。