Romero Gómez M, Vargas J, Utrilla D, Rufo M C, Otero M A, Chavez M, Larraona J L, Castilla L, Guerrero P, Grande L, Castro Fernández M
Seccione de Aparato Digestivo, Hospital Universitario de Valme, Sevilla.
Gastroenterol Hepatol. 1998 Jun-Jul;21(6):267-71.
To know the influence of upper gastrointestinal bleeding in diagnostic methods of H. pylori infection.
We prospectively studied patients with peptic ulcers: 55 with upper gastrointestinal bleeding and 62 without upper gastrointestinal bleeding. We analysed the results of culture, urease test, Gram, histology and serological test IgG and IgA in both groups. H. pylori infection was determined by a positive culture or positive urease test and histology.
Patients with upper gastrointestinal bleeding were older, but there were not statistical differences in sex, H. pylori prevalence infection or duodenal or gastric ulcers between patients with and without upper gastrointestinal bleeding. 78% having H. pylori infection. The urease test had a false negative rate in patients with upper gastrointestinal bleeding of 22% but only 3% in patients without upper gastrointestinal bleeding (p < 0.05). The culture, histology and Gram had higher false negative rate in upper gastrointestinal bleeding group than in non upper gastrointestinal bleeding group but without statistical significance. All patients with false negative urease test had antral culture positive.
Urease test has a high false negative rate when is studied in patients with peptic ulcers and upper gastrointestinal bleeding. Caution should be made if urease test was used alone for diagnosis in patients with upper gastrointestinal bleeding. Urease test and culture together could be a good diagnostic method.
了解上消化道出血对幽门螺杆菌感染诊断方法的影响。
我们对消化性溃疡患者进行了前瞻性研究:55例有上消化道出血,62例无消化道出血。我们分析了两组的培养、尿素酶试验、革兰氏染色、组织学以及血清学检测IgG和IgA的结果。幽门螺杆菌感染通过培养阳性或尿素酶试验阳性及组织学检查来确定。
有上消化道出血的患者年龄较大,但有和无上消化道出血的患者在性别、幽门螺杆菌感染率或十二指肠或胃溃疡方面无统计学差异。78%的患者感染幽门螺杆菌。尿素酶试验在有上消化道出血的患者中假阴性率为22%,而在无上消化道出血的患者中仅为3%(p<0.05)。培养、组织学和革兰氏染色在上消化道出血组中的假阴性率高于无消化道出血组,但无统计学意义。所有尿素酶试验假阴性的患者胃窦培养均为阳性。
在消化性溃疡合并上消化道出血的患者中进行研究时,尿素酶试验有较高的假阴性率。对上消化道出血患者单独使用尿素酶试验进行诊断时应谨慎。尿素酶试验和培养联合使用可能是一种较好的诊断方法。