Henkes H, Nahser H C, Berg-Dammer E, Weber W, Lange S, Kühne D
Klinik für Allgemeine Röntgendiagnostik und Neuroradiologie, Universität Witten/Herdecke, Bochum, Germany.
Neurol Res. 1998 Sep;20(6):479-92. doi: 10.1080/01616412.1998.11740552.
The purposes of this study were to determine the safety and efficacy of embolization of brain AVMs prior to radiosurgery and to evaluate the total obliteration rate achieved. The brain AVMs of 64 patients were subselectively embolized mainly with NBCA, platinum microcoils and/or PVA. The aim of embolization was the reduction of the target volume and/or the elimination of vascular structures bearing an increased risk of hemorrhage. Presenting symptoms were intracranial hemorrhage in 33 patients, a seizure disorder in 21 patients, and headache in 6 patients. Four AVMs had been detected as an incidental finding. The initial AVM volume was in the range of 0.5 to 84 cc (mean 17 cc). Grading of the AVMs according to the Spetzler-Martin scale showed the following distribution: grade I, 3x; II, 13x; III, 11x; IV, 17x; V, 4x; VI, 16x. A total of 300 endovascular procedures including 47 subselective catheterizations without and 253 with embolization were performed. A size reduction of the AVMs between 10% and 95% (mean 63%, median 70%) was achieved. Neurological symptoms due to treatment complications were transient in 12 patients, of minor clinical significance but permanent in 4 patients. Following radiosurgery, one patient died due to recurrent intracerebral hemorrhage. Three patients are doing well but refused final follow-up angiography. A total of 30 patients is currently within the latency interval after radiosurgery. Radiosurgery failed to obliterate the embolized AVMs in 16 patients. Angiography confirmed complete nidus obliteration in 14 patients. The endovascular treatment of brain AVMs prior to radiosurgery proved safe and effective and may be considered in either high grade or incidental AVMs. AVM obliteration after embolization and radiosurgery is less frequently achieved than after stereotactic irradiation of primarily small AVMs.
本研究的目的是确定放射外科手术前脑动静脉畸形(AVM)栓塞的安全性和有效性,并评估实现的完全闭塞率。64例患者的脑AVM主要用NBCA、铂微线圈和/或聚乙烯醇(PVA)进行超选择性栓塞。栓塞的目的是减少目标体积和/或消除具有增加出血风险的血管结构。出现的症状为33例患者颅内出血,21例患者癫痫发作,6例患者头痛。4例AVM为偶然发现。初始AVM体积在0.5至84立方厘米(平均17立方厘米)范围内。根据Spetzler-Martin量表对AVM进行分级,显示如下分布:I级,3例;II级,13例;III级,11例;IV级,17例;V级,4例;VI级,16例。共进行了300次血管内手术,包括47次无栓塞的超选择性插管和253次有栓塞的超选择性插管。AVM体积缩小了10%至95%(平均63%,中位数70%)。治疗并发症导致的神经症状在12例患者中为短暂性,临床意义较小,但在4例患者中为永久性。放射外科手术后,1例患者因复发性脑出血死亡。3例患者情况良好,但拒绝进行最终随访血管造影。目前共有30例患者处于放射外科手术后的潜伏期。放射外科未能使16例患者栓塞的AVM闭塞。血管造影证实14例患者的病灶完全闭塞。放射外科手术前对脑AVM进行血管内治疗被证明是安全有效的,对于高级别或偶然发现的AVM均可考虑。与主要对小型AVM进行立体定向照射后相比,栓塞和放射外科手术后AVM闭塞的情况较少见。