Raikin S M, Landsman J C, Alexander V A, Froimson M I, Plaxton N A
Mount Sinai Medical Center, Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Cleveland, OH 44106, USA.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1998 Aug(353):231-7. doi: 10.1097/00003086-199808000-00027.
Empirical clinical observation suggests that cigarette smoking had an inhibitory effect on long bone fracture healing, but this has not been proven scientifically. Forty female New Zealand White rabbits had midshaft tibial osteotomies performed and plated. These were divided randomly into two groups receiving either systemic nicotine or saline (placebo). Lateral radiographs were taken at 4, 6, and 8 weeks that showed a 17.2% average difference in callus formation between the two groups and a significant lag in formation of cortical continuity in the nicotine group. The rabbits were sacrificed 8 weeks after fracture, and healing was compared biomechanically. Three (13%) fractures showed no clinical evidence of union in the nicotine group, whereas all fractures in the control group healed. Biomechanical testing showed the nicotine exposed bones to be 26% weaker in three-point bending than were those exposed to placebo.
临床经验观察表明,吸烟对长骨骨折愈合有抑制作用,但这尚未得到科学证实。40只雌性新西兰白兔接受了胫骨中段截骨术并进行了钢板固定。这些兔子被随机分为两组,分别接受全身尼古丁或生理盐水(安慰剂)。在第4、6和8周拍摄侧位X线片,结果显示两组之间骨痂形成的平均差异为17.2%,且尼古丁组皮质连续性形成明显滞后。骨折8周后对兔子实施安乐死,并对愈合情况进行生物力学比较。尼古丁组有3例(13%)骨折无临床愈合迹象,而对照组所有骨折均愈合。生物力学测试显示,暴露于尼古丁的骨骼在三点弯曲试验中的强度比暴露于安慰剂的骨骼弱26%。