Bothur S, Blomqvist J E, Isaksson S
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Länssjukhuset, Halmstad, Sweden.
J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 1998 Sep;56(9):1029-33; discussion 1033-4. doi: 10.1016/s0278-2391(98)90248-8.
This study compared single maxillary surgery and a two-jaw procedure in patients who underwent one-piece Le Fort I advancement without bone grafting.
Fifty-three patients had Le Fort I osteotomy performed using a standard technique. Twenty-two patients had maxillary surgery alone, and 31 patients additionally had a bilateral sagittal split ramus osteotomy performed. Both rigid and nonrigid fixation were used. The postoperative movement of the maxilla was investigated, comparing cephalograms taken preoperatively, 2 to 3 days postoperatively, and at least 6 months postoperatively. A computer program was used to superimpose the three radiographs.
No difference in postoperative stability was found when the two surgical procedures were compared, and no correlation between magnitude of advancement and degree of relapse could be identified (P > .05). Nonrigid fixation in patients receiving only maxillary surgery resulted in greater postoperative forward movement of the maxilla (P = .022).
This study indicates that postoperative stability of the maxilla in a two-jaw procedure is equivalent to that of single maxillary surgery. Nonrigid fixation in single maxillary surgery reduces the need for postoperative orthodontics.
本研究比较了在未进行植骨的整块Le Fort I型前徙手术患者中,单上颌骨手术和双颌手术的效果。
53例患者采用标准技术进行Le Fort I型截骨术。22例患者仅接受上颌骨手术,31例患者还额外进行了双侧矢状劈开下颌支截骨术。采用了坚固内固定和非坚固内固定。通过比较术前、术后2至3天以及术后至少6个月拍摄的头颅侧位片,研究上颌骨的术后移动情况。使用计算机程序对三张X线片进行叠加。
比较两种手术方法时,未发现术后稳定性存在差异,且前徙幅度与复发程度之间未发现相关性(P >.05)。仅接受上颌骨手术的患者采用非坚固内固定导致上颌骨术后向前移动更大(P =.022)。
本研究表明,双颌手术中上颌骨的术后稳定性与单上颌骨手术相当。单上颌骨手术中的非坚固内固定减少了术后正畸治疗的需求。