Brady J P, Snyder J W, Hasbargen J A
Nephrology Specialists, PC, Munster, IN 46321, USA.
Am J Kidney Dis. 1998 Sep;32(3):415-8. doi: 10.1053/ajkd.1998.v32.pm9740157.
The percentage of nosocomial vancomycin-resistant enterococci (VRE) has been increasing rapidly in the United States. This has recently resulted in recommendations to reserve vancomycin use for cases with proven resistance to other antimicrobials. We prospectively investigated the incidence of VRE in our dialysis population and compared it with a control group of 40 clinic patients with chronic renal insufficiency (CRI) who had a serum creatinine level greater than 1.5 mg/dL, but were not undergoing dialysis. The incidence of VRE on our campus is almost 10%, which is similar to US data. We studied 50 chronic hemodialysis (HD) patients and 50 peritoneal dialysis (PD) patients. Each patient had a rectal swab test performed and cultured for the presence of enterococci. Antimicrobial exposures over the 6 months before the initial swab test were reviewed in each patient. At least one repeated swab test was performed in 30 CRI, 45 HD, and 37 PD patients. From the initial swab culture, vancomycin-sensitive enterococci (VSE) were isolated in 65% of CRI, 54% of HD, and 70% of PD patients. No CRI or HD patients had VRE isolated and 2% (1 of 50) of PD patients had VRE isolated. The remaining patients had no enterococci isolated. Review of antimicrobial exposures in the 6 months before the initial swab test showed 0% of CRI, 32% of HD, and 36% of PD patients received vancomycin. Other antimicrobials were administered to 40% of CRI, 46% of HD, and 78% of PD patients in the same time period. In the month immediately preceding the initial swab test, 0% of CRI, 12% of HD, and 22% of PD patients received vancomycin and 18% of CRI, 20% of HD, and 36% of PD patients received other antimicrobials. Results from repeated cultures showed that 57% of CRI, 40% of HD, and 38% of PD patients changed their culture status related to VSE, VRE, or no enterococci present. Cultures of 342 swabs from 140 patients yielded three VRE isolates in two patients. We conclude that despite the frequent use of vancomycin and other antimicrobials, the incidence of VRE in our renal population is less than the reported incidence. Given this lack of VRE isolates, we recommend the continued judicious use of vancomycin in treating renal patients and continued enterococcal sensitivity surveillance.
在美国,医院内耐万古霉素肠球菌(VRE)的比例一直在迅速上升。最近,这导致了相关建议,即仅在已证实对其他抗菌药物耐药的情况下才使用万古霉素。我们前瞻性地调查了透析人群中VRE的发生率,并将其与40名慢性肾功能不全(CRI)门诊患者的对照组进行比较,这些患者血清肌酐水平大于1.5mg/dL,但未接受透析。我们校园内VRE的发生率接近10%,这与美国的数据相似。我们研究了50名慢性血液透析(HD)患者和50名腹膜透析(PD)患者。对每位患者进行直肠拭子检测并培养以检测肠球菌的存在。回顾了每位患者在初次拭子检测前6个月内的抗菌药物暴露情况。30名CRI患者、45名HD患者和37名PD患者至少进行了一次重复拭子检测。从初次拭子培养中,在65%的CRI患者、54%的HD患者和70%的PD患者中分离出万古霉素敏感肠球菌(VSE)。没有CRI或HD患者分离出VRE,2%(50名中的1名)的PD患者分离出VRE。其余患者未分离出肠球菌。回顾初次拭子检测前6个月内的抗菌药物暴露情况显示,0%的CRI患者、32%的HD患者和36%的PD患者接受了万古霉素治疗。在同一时期,40%的CRI患者、46%的HD患者和78%的PD患者使用了其他抗菌药物。在初次拭子检测前的一个月内,0%的CRI患者、12%的HD患者和22%的PD患者接受了万古霉素治疗,18%的CRI患者、20%的HD患者和36%的PD患者接受了其他抗菌药物治疗。重复培养的结果显示,57%的CRI患者、40%的HD患者和38%的PD患者在VSE、VRE或无肠球菌存在方面改变了培养状态。来自140名患者的342份拭子培养物在两名患者中产生了3株VRE分离株。我们得出结论,尽管频繁使用万古霉素和其他抗菌药物,但我们肾脏患者群体中VRE的发生率低于报告的发生率。鉴于VRE分离株较少,我们建议在治疗肾脏患者时继续谨慎使用万古霉素,并继续进行肠球菌敏感性监测。