Verkoczy L K, Berinstein N L
Department of Immunology and Department of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Nucleic Acids Res. 1998 Oct 1;26(19):4497-507. doi: 10.1093/nar/26.19.4497.
Differential display PCR (DD RT-PCR) has been extensively used for analysis of differential gene expression, but continues to be hampered by technical limitations that impair its effectiveness. In order to isolate novel genes co-expressing with human RAG1, we have developed an effective, multi-tiered screening/purification approach which effectively complements the standard DD RT-PCR methodology. In 'primary' screens, standard DD RT-PCR was used, detecting 22 reproducible differentially expressed amplicons between clonally related cell variants with differential constitutive expression of RAG mRNAs. 'Secondary' screens used differential display (DD) amplicons as probes in low and high stringency northern blotting. Eight of 22 independent DD amplicons detected nine independent differentially expressed transcripts. 'Tertiary' screens used reconfirmed amplicons as probes in northern analysis of multiple RAG-and RAG+sources. Reconfirmed DD amplicons detected six independent RAG co-expressing transcripts. All DD amplicons reconfirmed by northern blot were a heterogeneous mixture of cDNAs, necessitating further purification to isolate single cDNAs prior to subcloning and sequencing. To effectively select the appropriate cDNAs from DD amplicons, we excised and eluted the cDNA(s) directly from regions of prior northern blots in which differentially expressed transcripts were detected. Sequences of six purified cDNA clones specifically detecting RAG co-expressing transcripts included matches to portions of the human RAG2 and BSAP regions and to four novel partial cDNAs (three with homologies to human ESTs). Overall, our results also suggest that even when using clonally related variants from the same cell line in addition to all appropriate internal controls previously reported, further screening and purification steps are still required in order to efficiently and specifically isolate differentially expressed genes by DD RT-PCR.
差异显示PCR(DD RT-PCR)已被广泛用于分析差异基因表达,但仍受到技术限制的阻碍,这些限制削弱了其有效性。为了分离与人类RAG1共表达的新基因,我们开发了一种有效的多层筛选/纯化方法,该方法有效地补充了标准的DD RT-PCR方法。在“初级”筛选中,使用标准的DD RT-PCR,检测到在RAG mRNA组成型表达不同的克隆相关细胞变体之间有22个可重复的差异表达扩增子。“二级”筛选使用差异显示(DD)扩增子作为探针进行低严谨度和高严谨度的Northern印迹分析。22个独立的DD扩增子中有8个检测到9个独立的差异表达转录本。“三级”筛选使用重新确认的扩增子作为探针,对多个RAG和RAG+来源进行Northern分析。重新确认的DD扩增子检测到6个独立的与RAG共表达的转录本。通过Northern印迹重新确认的所有DD扩增子都是cDNA的异质混合物,在亚克隆和测序之前需要进一步纯化以分离单个cDNA。为了从DD扩增子中有效地选择合适的cDNA,我们直接从先前Northern印迹中检测到差异表达转录本的区域切下并洗脱cDNA。六个特异性检测与RAG共表达转录本的纯化cDNA克隆的序列与人类RAG2和BSAP区域的部分以及四个新的部分cDNA(三个与人类EST有同源性)相匹配。总体而言,我们的结果还表明,即使除了先前报道的所有适当内部对照之外,使用来自同一细胞系的克隆相关变体,为了通过DD RT-PCR有效且特异性地分离差异表达基因,仍然需要进一步的筛选和纯化步骤。