Newman C B, Melmed S, George A, Torigian D, Duhaney M, Snyder P, Young W, Klibanski A, Molitch M E, Gagel R, Sheeler L, Cook D, Malarkey W, Jackson I, Vance M L, Barkan A, Frohman L, Kleinberg D L
Department of Medicine, New York University, New York, USA.
J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 1998 Sep;83(9):3034-40. doi: 10.1210/jcem.83.9.5109.
The effects of octreotide (up to 5 yr) as primary treatment in 26 patients with acromegaly were compared with those in 81 patients with acromegaly who received octreotide as secondary or adjunctive therapy after previous surgery and/or pituitary radiation. These patients were part of a multicenter study that took place between 1989-1995. The study was divided into 3 phases beginning with a 1-month placebo-controlled treatment period followed by a 1-month washout period. In the second phase, patients were randomized to treatment with either 100 or 250 micrograms octreotide, sc, every 8 h for 6 months. Octreotide was then discontinued for 1 month and reinitiated at the lower dose for a total mean treatment duration of 39 months. The dose was titrated by each investigator to improve each patient's individual response, which included improvement in symptoms and signs of acromegaly as well as reduction of GH and insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I) into the normal range. In the second phase of the study, in which patients were randomized to either 100 or 250 micrograms octreotide, three times daily, mean integrated GH and IGF-I concentrations after 3 and 6 months were equivalent in the primary and secondary treatment groups. During long term open label treatment, mean GH fell from 32.7 +/- 5.2 to 6.0 +/- 1.7 micrograms/L 2 h after octreotide injection in the primary therapy group and remained suppressed for a mean period of 24 months (range, 3-60 months). The mean final daily dose was 777 micrograms. In the patients receiving secondary treatment, mean GH fell from 30.2 +/- 7.6 to 5.6 +/- 1.1 micrograms/L after 3 months and remained suppressed for the remainder of the study (average dose, 635 micrograms daily). Mean IGF-I concentrations fell from 5.2 +/- 0.5 x 10(3) U/L (primary treatment group) and 4.7 +/- 0.4 x 10(3) U/L (secondary treatment group) to a mean of 2.2 +/- 0.3 x 10(3) U/L in both groups after 3 months of open label treatment and remained suppressed. IGF-I was reduced into the normal range during at least half of the study visits in 68% of the primary treatment group and in 62% of the secondary treatment group. Patients whose GH levels fell to at least 2 SD below the baseline mean GH were considered responders. There was no significant difference in the percentage of responders in the primary and secondary treatment groups (70% vs. 61%), nor was there a statistical difference in the mean GH concentrations between the groups. Symptoms of headache, increased perspiration, fatigue, and joint pain were reported at baseline by 46%, 73%, 69%, and 85%, respectively, of patients in the primary therapy group and improved during 3 yr of octreotide treatment in 50-100%. Similarly, these acromegaly-related symptoms were reported by 62%, 58%, 78%, and 60% of patients in the secondary therapy group, and improvement was noted in 62-88%. Pituitary magnetic resonance imaging scans were available in 13 of 26 patients in the primary treatment group before and after 6 months of octreotide treatment. Tumor shrinkage was observed in 6 of 13 patients, with reduction in tumor volume greater than 25% in only 3. Of 6 patients with documented tumor shrinkage, IGF-I was reduced into the normal range in 4 patients. Of the 7 remaining patients in whom tumor shrinkage was less than 10%, IGF-I was reduced into the normal range in 4 patients. Of the 7 remaining patients in whom tumor shrinkage was less than 10%, IGF-I was reduced into the normal range in 5 patients. The degree of tumor shrinkage did not correlate with the percent reduction in IGF-I or GH. In summary, octreotide was equally effective in 26 previously untreated acromegalic patients (primary treatment group) and 81 patients previously treated with either surgery or pituitary radiation (secondary treatment group). These observations call into question the current practice of surgical resection of all newly diagnosed GH-secreting pituitary adenomas regardless of the likelihood of cure. (AB
将26例肢端肥大症患者接受奥曲肽作为初始治疗(长达5年)的效果,与81例肢端肥大症患者接受奥曲肽作为先前手术和/或垂体放疗后的二线或辅助治疗的效果进行了比较。这些患者是1989年至1995年间一项多中心研究的一部分。该研究分为3个阶段,首先是1个月的安慰剂对照治疗期,随后是1个月的洗脱期。在第二阶段,患者被随机分为接受每8小时皮下注射100或250微克奥曲肽治疗6个月。然后停用奥曲肽1个月,并以较低剂量重新开始治疗,总平均治疗持续时间为39个月。每位研究者对剂量进行滴定以改善每个患者的个体反应,这包括肢端肥大症症状和体征的改善以及将生长激素(GH)和胰岛素样生长因子I(IGF-I)降低至正常范围。在研究的第二阶段,患者被随机分为每日3次接受100或250微克奥曲肽治疗,3个月和6个月后,初始治疗组和二线治疗组的平均整合GH和IGF-I浓度相当。在长期开放标签治疗期间(长达5年),初始治疗组奥曲肽注射后2小时平均GH从32.7±5.2微克/升降至6.0±1.7微克/升,并在平均24个月(范围3 - 60个月)内保持抑制状态。平均最终每日剂量为777微克。在接受二线治疗的患者中,3个月后平均GH从30.2±7.6微克/升降至5.6±1.1微克/升,并在研究的其余时间内保持抑制状态(平均剂量每日635微克)。开放标签治疗3个月后,两组平均IGF-I浓度从5.2±0.5×10³U/L(初始治疗组)和4.7±0.4×10³U/L(二线治疗组)降至平均2.2±0.3×10³U/L并保持抑制状态。在初始治疗组68%的患者和二线治疗组62%的患者中,IGF-I在至少一半的研究访视期间降至正常范围。GH水平降至基线平均GH至少2个标准差以下的患者被视为反应者。初始治疗组和二线治疗组反应者的百分比无显著差异(70%对61%),两组之间的平均GH浓度也无统计学差异。初始治疗组分别有46%、73%、69%和85%的患者在基线时报告有头痛、多汗、疲劳和关节痛症状,在奥曲肽治疗3年期间50% - 100%的症状得到改善。同样,二线治疗组分别有62%、58%、78%和60%的患者报告有这些肢端肥大症相关症状,62% - 88%的症状得到改善。26例初始治疗组患者中有13例在奥曲肽治疗6个月前后可获得垂体磁共振成像扫描。13例患者中有6例观察到肿瘤缩小,仅3例肿瘤体积缩小大于25%。在记录到肿瘤缩小的6例患者中,4例患者的IGF-I降至正常范围。在其余7例肿瘤缩小小于10%的患者中,5例患者的IGF-I降至正常范围。肿瘤缩小程度与IGF-I或GH降低的百分比无关。总之奥曲肽在26例先前未治疗的肢端肥大症患者(初始治疗组)和81例先前接受过手术或垂体放疗的患者(二线治疗组)中同样有效。这些观察结果对目前无论治愈可能性如何都对所有新诊断的分泌GH的垂体腺瘤进行手术切除的做法提出了质疑。 (AB)