Bachet J, Goudot B, Dreyfus G, Brodaty D, Lentdecker D E, Dubois C, Guilmet D
Service de chirurgie cardiovasculaire, hôpital Foch, Suresnes, France.
Chirurgie. 1998 Jun;123(3):229-37; discussion 238. doi: 10.1016/s0001-4001(98)80114-1.
In 1977, the use of gelatine-resorcine-formaline (GRF) biological glue during surgery of acute type A aortic dissection was proposed. The present study retrospectively analyses the late results obtained with this adjunct in an experience extending over a 20-year period.
From January 1977 to July 1997, 193 patients (139 males and 54 females) aged from 15 to 79 years (mean age: 53 +/- 14 years) underwent an emergency operation for type A aortic dissection in our institution. All patients suffering from acute type A dissection and 162 (84%) were operated on within 48 hours after the onset of symptoms. Twenty-eight patients (15.2%) had Marfan's syndrome. In all patients the ascending aorta was replaced and the aortic stumps were reinforced with the GRF glue. In 43 patients (22.2%), the aortic valve was replaced either independently (5 cases-2.5%) or by means of a composite graft (35 cases-19.5%). Recently three patients underwent a complete replacement of the ascending aorta and coronary reimplantation with preservation of the native aortic valve. Because of the location of the intimal tear, the aortic replacement was extended to the transverse arch in 58 patients (30%).
Hospital mortality amounted to 21% (40 patients) (22.8% in patients with arch replacement and 20.3% in patients without arch replacement) (ns). The survivors were surveyed from 2 months to 20 years post-operatively (cumulative follow-up: 856 pt/years, mean follow-up: 85 +/- 66 months). During this period of time, 23 patients (15%) had to be reoperated on for a total of 29 procedures. Six of those patients (26%) died at reoperation. At univariate analysis, presence of Marfan's syndrome (P < 0.05) and absence of arch replacement (P < 0.02) were determinant risk factors for reoperation. Emergency (P < 0.01) and thoraco-abdominal replacement (P < 0.04) were determinant risk-factors of death at reoperation. The actuarial freedom from reoperation (Kaplan-Meier, CI: 95%) was: 96.5% (90.9-98.2), 87.6% (79.8-92.7), 80.9% (70.8-88.1), 66.4% (51.1-78.9) at one, 5, 10 and 15 years, respectively. A total of 36 patients (27.7%) died during follow-up. Presence of Marfan's syndrome (P < 0.01), reoperation (P < 0.02), stroke (P < 0.05), cardiac failure (P < 0.05) were determinant risk factors of late mortality. The actuarial late survival rate (Kaplan-Meier. CI: 95%), including hospital mortality, was: 71.5% (64.3-77.8), 66% (58.3-73), 56.4% (47.7-64.7), 46.3% (36.4-56.5) at one, 5, 10 and 15 years.
The GRF glue has proved to be extremely useful during initial emergency surgery for acute type A dissection, making the procedure much easier and safer. Through this operative improvement, the use of the GRF glue seems to have a beneficial influence on the late results which, however, depend mainly on the patient's basic condition.
1977年,有人提出在急性A型主动脉夹层手术中使用明胶-间苯二酚-甲醛(GRF)生物胶。本研究回顾性分析了在长达20年的经验中使用这种辅助材料所获得的远期结果。
1977年1月至1997年7月,193例年龄在15至79岁(平均年龄:53±14岁)的患者(139例男性和54例女性)在我院接受了急性A型主动脉夹层的急诊手术。所有急性A型夹层患者中,162例(84%)在症状发作后48小时内接受了手术。28例患者(15.2%)患有马凡综合征。所有患者均行升主动脉置换术,并用GRF胶加固主动脉残端。43例患者(22.2%)单独(5例-2.5%)或通过复合移植物(35例-19.5%)置换了主动脉瓣。最近,3例患者接受了升主动脉完全置换和冠状动脉再植入术,同时保留了天然主动脉瓣。由于内膜撕裂的位置,58例患者(30%)的主动脉置换术延伸至横弓。
医院死亡率为21%(40例患者)(弓部置换患者中为22.8%,未行弓部置换患者中为20.3%)(无显著性差异)。对幸存者进行了术后2个月至20年的随访(累积随访:856患者/年,平均随访:85±66个月)。在此期间,23例患者(15%)因总共29次手术而再次接受手术。其中6例患者(26%)在再次手术时死亡。单因素分析显示,马凡综合征的存在(P<0.05)和未行弓部置换(P<0.02)是再次手术的决定性危险因素。急诊手术(P<0.01)和胸腹联合置换术(P<0.04)是再次手术时死亡的决定性危险因素。再次手术的精算无复发率(Kaplan-Meier法,95%置信区间)在1年、5年、10年和15年分别为:96.5%(90.9-98.2)、87.6%(79.8-92.7)、80.9%(70.8-88.1)、66.4%(51.1-78.9)。共有36例患者(27.7%)在随访期间死亡。马凡综合征的存在(P<0.01)、再次手术(P<0.02)、中风(P<0.05)、心力衰竭(P<0.05)是远期死亡的决定性危险因素。包括医院死亡率在内的精算远期生存率(Kaplan-Meier法,95%置信区间)在1年、5年、10年和15年分别为:71.5%(64.3-77.8)、66%(58.3-73)、56.4%(47.7-64.7)、46.3%(36.4-56.5)。
GRF胶已被证明在急性A型夹层的初次急诊手术中非常有用,使手术更加简便和安全。通过这种手术改进,GRF胶的使用似乎对远期结果有有益影响,然而,远期结果主要取决于患者的基础状况。