Calton R, Satija T, Dhanoa J, Jaison T M, David T
Department of Cardiology and Internal Medicine, Christian Medical College and Hospital, Ludhiana.
Indian Heart J. 1998 May-Jun;50(3):300-6.
One hundred consecutive patients (81 male and 19 female) with unstable angina pectoris undergoing coronary angiography were divided according to Braunwald's clinical classification. Seventeen (17%) patients had new onset angina (class I), 68 (68%) sub-acute angina (class II) and 15 (15%) had acute rest angina (class III). Twenty-seven (27%) patients had secondary unstable angina pectoris (class A), 49 (49%) primary unstable angina (class B) and 24 (24%) had post-infarction unstable angina (class C). ST-T wave changes on ECG were present in 54 (54%) while absent in 46 (46%) patients. On coronary angiography, 26 (26%) patients had single vessel disease, 30 (30%) double vessel disease and 39 (39%) patients had triple vessel disease. Five (5%) patients were found to have normal coronaries. Classification of patients according to Braunwald's clinical classification showed single vessel disease to be higher in class I as compared to class II (47% vs 22%; p = 0.04) and classes III (47% vs 20%; p<0.01). Single vessel disease was found to be higher in class C as compared to class B (41.7% vs 16.4; p = 0.01). Double vessel disease was higher in class B as compared to class A (40.8% vs 18.5%, p = 0.04). Triple vessel disease incidence was not found to be significantly different among different clinical classes. Morphology of coronary artery lesions was classified according to Ambrose's classification. Out of the total of 248 lesions in the whole study group, there were 68 (27.42%) concentric lesions, 55 (22.18%) eccentric type I lesions, 23 (9.27%) eccentric type II lesions, 42 (16.94%) multiple irregularity lesions and 60 (24.19%) totally occluded lesions. Concentric lesions were found to be higher in class C as compared to class B (40% vs 19.8%; p = 0.014). Statistically significant difference was not present in the distribution of other morphological type of lesions among different clinical classes. In the whole study group, intra-luminal thrombus was found to be present in 17 (17%) of patients. Distribution of intra-luminal thrombus according to Braunwald's classification showed that none of the patients in class I had intra-luminal thrombus, while 13 (19.1%) patients in class II and 4(26.7%) in class III had intra-luminal thrombus. The difference in the occurrence of intra-luminal thrombus between class I and class II (p = 0.004) and class I and class III (p = 0 .03 was found to be significant. Thus, majority of patients undergoing coronary angiography had primary sub-acute rest angina. Single vessel disease was higher in new onset angina. Patients with unstable angina pectoris and ST-T changes on ECG had higher number of lesions per patient and higher eccentric type I lesions. Intra-luminal thrombus was more frequently encountered with acute rest angina. However, the distribution of different morphological type of lesions on coronary angiography did not differ significantly in different clinical classes of unstable angina pectoris divided according to Braunwald's classification.
连续100例接受冠状动脉造影的不稳定型心绞痛患者(81例男性,19例女性)根据Braunwald临床分类进行分组。17例(17%)患者为初发型心绞痛(I级),68例(68%)为亚急性心绞痛(II级),15例(15%)为急性静息性心绞痛(III级)。27例(27%)患者为继发性不稳定型心绞痛(A级),49例(49%)为原发性不稳定型心绞痛(B级),24例(24%)为梗死后不稳定型心绞痛(C级)。心电图ST - T波改变的患者有54例(54%),无改变的有46例(46%)。冠状动脉造影显示,26例(26%)患者为单支血管病变,30例(30%)为双支血管病变,39例(39%)患者为三支血管病变。5例(5%)患者冠状动脉正常。根据Braunwald临床分类对患者进行分组显示,I级患者单支血管病变的比例高于II级(47%对22%;p = 0.04)和III级(47%对20%;p<0.01)。C级患者单支血管病变的比例高于B级(41.7%对16.4%;p = 0.01)。B级患者双支血管病变的比例高于A级(40.8%对18.5%,p = 0.04)。不同临床分级之间三支血管病变的发生率未发现显著差异。冠状动脉病变形态根据Ambrose分类进行划分。在整个研究组的248处病变中,有68处(27.42%)为同心性病变,55处(22.18%)为偏心I型病变,23处(9.27%)为偏心II型病变,42处(16.94%)为多发不规则病变,60处(24.19%)为完全闭塞病变。C级患者同心性病变的比例高于B级(40%对19.8%;p = 0.014)。不同临床分级之间其他形态类型病变的分布未发现统计学显著差异。在整个研究组中,17例(17%)患者发现有腔内血栓。根据Braunwald分类,腔内血栓的分布显示I级患者中无腔内血栓,而II级患者中有13例(19.1%)、III级患者中有4例(26.7%)有腔内血栓。I级与II级(p = 0.004)以及I级与III级(p = 0.03)之间腔内血栓发生情况的差异具有显著性。因此,大多数接受冠状动脉造影的患者为原发性亚急性静息性心绞痛。初发型心绞痛中单支血管病变较多。心电图有ST - T改变的不稳定型心绞痛患者每位患者的病变数量较多,偏心I型病变较多。急性静息性心绞痛中更常出现腔内血栓。然而根据Braunwald分类划分的不同临床分级的不稳定型心绞痛患者中,冠状动脉造影不同形态类型病变的分布没有显著差异。