Mehrotra A, Chandra T
Department of Pathology, King George's Medical College, Lucknow, India.
Indian J Exp Biol. 1998 Feb;36(2):162-6.
The object of the present study was to determine the statistical significance of AgNOR counts in fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) smears and corresponding paraffin sections by using an one step silver colloidal staining method. Ninety five cases (31 benign and 64 malignant) were taken and a correlation between smears and sections was studied by two different observers. The total number of mean (SD) AgNOR counts was significantly higher in FNAC smears in benign (3.081 +/- .753) and malignant (7.101 +/- 1.544) neoplasms in comparison to paraffin sections in the same group of cases. FNAC smears had a cut off point 4 with proliferation index 1% in benign tumors and 97.5% in malignant tumors. Sections had an overlapping of AgNOR counts (5-7) with proliferation index 3.8 and 82% for benign and malignant groups respectively. The difference in the coefficient of variations was 3% in benign group and 2% in malignant group in FNAC smears while sections had 6 and 8% difference in the coefficient of variations. Smears present a superior staining and accurate number of AgNOR dots in nucleus as compared to paraffin sections. Therefore the results suggest that AgNOR technique can be successfully used in FNAC smears in comparison to paraffin sections to differentiate benign and malignant tumors in routine laboratory diagnosis.
本研究的目的是通过一步银胶体染色法确定细针穿刺细胞学(FNAC)涂片和相应石蜡切片中核仁组成区嗜银蛋白(AgNOR)计数的统计学意义。选取了95例病例(31例良性和64例恶性),由两名不同的观察者研究涂片和切片之间的相关性。与同一组病例的石蜡切片相比,良性(3.081±0.753)和恶性(7.101±1.544)肿瘤的FNAC涂片中平均(标准差)AgNOR计数总数显著更高。FNAC涂片在良性肿瘤中的增殖指数为1%时的截断点为4,在恶性肿瘤中为97.5%。切片中AgNOR计数(5 - 7)有重叠,良性和恶性组的增殖指数分别为3.8和82%。FNAC涂片中良性组变异系数的差异为3%,恶性组为2%,而切片的变异系数差异为6%和8%。与石蜡切片相比,涂片在细胞核中呈现出更好的染色效果和准确的AgNOR点数。因此,结果表明,与石蜡切片相比,AgNOR技术可成功用于FNAC涂片,以在常规实验室诊断中鉴别良性和恶性肿瘤。