Derelle J, Bertolo-Houriez E, Marchal F, Weber M, Virion J M, Vidailhet M
Service de pédiatrie 1, Hôpital d'Enfants, Vandoeuvre-lès-Nancy, France.
Arch Pediatr. 1998 Apr;5(4):371-7. doi: 10.1016/s0929-693x(98)80022-5.
Modifications of bronchial secretions in cystic fibrosis patients account for the long-lasting use of mucolytic agents, despite the lack of adequately controlled clinical studies supporting this approach. Hyperviscosity of bronchial secretions mainly depend on their high DNA content, as a result of degradation of polymorphonuclear neutrophils mobilized by infection and inflammation. This phenomenon has led to the treatment of respiratory complications with human recombinant deoxyribonuclease (dornase alfa). In the present study, we compared the clinical and respiratory outcome in patients receiving mucolytic agents followed by dornase alfa, each for 1 year.
Fifty-four patients, aged 5 years or more, have been prospectively followed for 2 years. They received first a 12-month association of mesna (two nebulisations per day) and oral ambroxol (60 mg per day, divided in two doses), followed by a 12-month treatment with one daily aerosol of dornase alfa only (2.5 mg per day). The primary end-points were the results of pulmonary function tests. Secondary end-points were subjective symptoms, bacterial colonization, consumption of antibiotics, and clinical tolerance.
At the end of the 12-month mucolytic therapy, a significant decrease of forced expiratory volume/second (FEV1, -10.5% as compared to baseline values) and forced vital capacity (FVC, -12.8%) was observed. At the end of 12-month dornase alfa, FEV1 and FVC had increased by 7.7 and 5.3%, respectively. This change was statistically significant only for FEV1 in most severely disabled patients. However, forced expiratory flow 25-75% (FEF 25-75) decreased during the 2 year period of observation, by 5.6% the first year and 4.9% the second year. The mean number of days with parenteral antibiotics did not statistically differ between both treatments, except for patients more than 15 years of age. In this subgroup, the mean number decreased from 40 days in the first year to 27 in the second year (P < 0.05). Acceptability of treatment by the patients themselves was better with dornase alfa than with mucolytic therapy. However, several episodes of hemoptysis, frequent in only one case, were associated with the treatment by dornase alfa.
Dornase alfa was associated with a stabilisation, and even a trend to improvement in pulmonary function tests. This stabilisation is by itself a very encouraging result. Long-term comparative studies are needed to evaluate the benefits of dornase alfa in the treatment of respiratory complications of cystic fibrosis and specify the optimal modalities of its use. Synergistic combinations with mucolytic therapy and/or anti-inflammatory drugs could be viewed as a future prospect.
尽管缺乏充分对照的临床研究支持,但囊性纤维化患者支气管分泌物的改变使得黏液溶解剂得以长期使用。支气管分泌物的高黏滞性主要取决于其高DNA含量,这是由感染和炎症调动的多形核中性粒细胞降解所致。这种现象促使人们使用重组人脱氧核糖核酸酶(多纳培南)来治疗呼吸并发症。在本研究中,我们比较了接受黏液溶解剂治疗1年,随后接受多纳培南治疗1年的患者的临床和呼吸结局。
54例年龄5岁及以上的患者进行了为期2年的前瞻性随访。他们首先接受了12个月的美司钠(每天雾化吸入两次)和口服氨溴索(每天60毫克,分两次服用)联合治疗,随后仅接受12个月的多纳培南每日一次雾化吸入治疗(每天2.5毫克)。主要终点是肺功能测试结果。次要终点是主观症状、细菌定植、抗生素使用量和临床耐受性。
在12个月的黏液溶解剂治疗结束时,观察到第一秒用力呼气容积(FEV1,与基线值相比下降了10.5%)和用力肺活量(FVC,下降了12.8%)显著降低。在12个月的多纳培南治疗结束时,FEV1和FVC分别增加了7.7%和5.3%。这种变化仅在最严重残疾的患者中,FEV1有统计学意义。然而,在2年的观察期内,25%-75%用力呼气流量(FEF 25-75)下降,第一年下降了5.6%,第二年下降了4.9%。除15岁以上患者外,两种治疗方法静脉使用抗生素的平均天数在统计学上没有差异。在这个亚组中,平均天数从第一年的40天降至第二年的27天(P<0.05)。患者对多纳培南治疗的接受度优于黏液溶解剂治疗。然而,多纳培南治疗出现了几例咯血事件,仅1例较为频繁。
多纳培南与肺功能测试的稳定甚至改善趋势相关。这种稳定本身就是一个非常令人鼓舞的结果。需要进行长期比较研究,以评估多纳培南在治疗囊性纤维化呼吸并发症中的益处,并确定其最佳使用方式。与黏液溶解剂治疗和/或抗炎药物的协同联合可能是未来的一个前景。