Stravynski A, Greenberg D
University of Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
Acta Psychiatr Scand. 1998 Sep;98(3):171-81. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0447.1998.tb10063.x.
This article critically reviews the effects of psychological treatment (exposure, cognitive restructuring, social skills training) and pharmacological treatment (MAOIs, reversible MAOIs, anxiolytics and SSRIs) of social phobia. Only controlled studies have been included, and their outcomes were assessed for improvement in anxiety and avoidance, social functioning and clinical status. Both psychological and pharmacological treatments resulted in a significant and meaningful reduction in anxiety and, in most cases, a weakening of the tendency to avoid. Although useful, the effects were not of such a magnitude as to result in remission. Reduction in anxiety was long-lasting in patients treated by psychological methods. The lessening of anxiety did not necessarily lead to meaningfully improved social functioning. The combination of psychological and pharmacological treatments was disappointing, and did not exceed the effects of psychological treatments alone. However, the most promising medications were not tested. Subtype of social phobia and additional diagnoses did not determine the response to treatment.
本文批判性地回顾了社交恐惧症的心理治疗(暴露疗法、认知重建、社交技能训练)和药物治疗(单胺氧化酶抑制剂、可逆性单胺氧化酶抑制剂、抗焦虑药和选择性5-羟色胺再摄取抑制剂)的效果。仅纳入了对照研究,并评估了其在焦虑和回避行为改善、社交功能及临床状态方面的结果。心理治疗和药物治疗均使焦虑显著且有意义地减轻,且在大多数情况下,回避倾向减弱。尽管有帮助,但效果未达到可实现缓解的程度。接受心理治疗的患者焦虑减轻具有持久性。焦虑减轻并不一定导致社交功能有意义地改善。心理治疗和药物治疗的联合效果令人失望,并未超过单纯心理治疗的效果。然而,最有前景的药物未进行测试。社交恐惧症的亚型及其他诊断并不能决定治疗反应。