Clusters of new identical mutants and the fate of underdominant mutations.

Given favorable environmental and demographic conditions, premeiotic clusters of identical mutations can produce a broad distribution of the initial frequency of underdominant alleles. Because of these clusters, new underdominant mutations may not necessarily be as rare in a population as previously assumed. The fixation of underdominant mutations, especially those with low heterozygous fitness, is increased when mutations appear in a cluster due to a genetic change that occurred before germline differentiation. Most restrictions on the fixation of underdominant mutations in a single population, such as strong genetic drift, weak selection against mutant heterozygotes, isolated population structure, inbreeding, meiotic drive, and selection in favor of mutant homozygotes can be relaxed or even dropped. Instead, the fate of strong underdominant mutations is determined mainly by ecological and genetic factors that affect the cluster size distribution of new premeiotic mutations. Accumulation of reproductive isolation by the fixation of underdominant mutations becomes more feasible with clusters, and mutation is not always the weakest force during this evolutionary process. The large mean and variance of reproductive success in many multicellular species make it possible that even underdominant mutations with very low heterozygous fitness could contribute substantially to reproductive isolation.