Deal L W, Shiono P H
Future Child. 1998 Summer-Fall;8(2):93-104.
In recent years, states have increasingly turned to managed care arrangements for financing and delivering health services to Medicaid beneficiaries. In 1996, approximately 40% of all Medicaid recipients were enrolled in some form of managed care. The rapid escalation of managed care in this population has been fueled by states' desire to slow the growth of Medicaid expenditures and by the trend toward managed care enrollment in the private health insurance industry. The effect of managed care on cost containment in the Medicaid program may be limited, however, because 85% to 90% of Medicaid managed care enrollees are women of childbearing age and children, who together account for 69% of Medicaid recipients, but only 26% of program costs. Nonetheless, the increase in managed care enrollment in this population may have a profound impact on health service delivery and health outcomes for U.S. children, approximately 20% of whom received health benefits through the Medicaid program in 1995. In the future, the proportion of Medicaid-eligible children enrolled in managed care will likely increase as a result of recent legislation that relaxed the requirement that states seek federal approval prior to mandating managed care enrollment for Medicaid beneficiaries. More states are relying on fully capitated arrangements as the preferred type of managed care for Medicaid recipients, despite the relative lack of experience many of these plans have in serving this low-income population. Moreover, managed care organizations have few incentives to enroll chronically or disabled children with higher-than-average expected costs. Without mechanisms in place that adequately adjust capitated rates to account for these higher-cost enrollees, managed care organizations may lose money, and children with the greatest health care needs may be underserved. As mandatory managed care enrollment for Medicaid recipients increases nationwide, states should carefully monitor changes in program costs and quality as well as implications for the delivery of pediatric health services and health outcomes.
近年来,各州越来越多地采用管理式医疗安排,为医疗补助受益人提供融资和医疗服务。1996年,约40%的医疗补助受助人参加了某种形式的管理式医疗。该人群中管理式医疗的迅速扩张,是由各州减缓医疗补助支出增长的愿望以及私人健康保险行业中管理式医疗参保的趋势推动的。然而,管理式医疗对医疗补助计划成本控制的效果可能有限,因为85%至90%的医疗补助管理式医疗参保人是育龄妇女和儿童,他们占医疗补助受助人的69%,但仅占计划成本的26%。尽管如此,该人群中管理式医疗参保人数的增加,可能会对美国儿童的医疗服务提供和健康结果产生深远影响,1995年约20%的美国儿童通过医疗补助计划获得了健康福利。未来,由于最近的立法放宽了各州在强制医疗补助受益人参加管理式医疗之前寻求联邦批准的要求,参加管理式医疗的符合医疗补助条件的儿童比例可能会增加。尽管许多这类计划在服务低收入人群方面相对缺乏经验,但越来越多的州将完全按人头付费的安排作为医疗补助受助人首选的管理式医疗类型。此外,管理式医疗组织几乎没有动力去招收预期成本高于平均水平的慢性病或残疾儿童。如果没有适当调整按人头付费率以考虑这些高成本参保人的机制,管理式医疗组织可能会亏损,而医疗需求最大的儿童可能得不到充分的服务。随着全国范围内强制医疗补助受益人参加管理式医疗的人数增加,各州应仔细监测计划成本和质量的变化,以及对儿科医疗服务提供和健康结果的影响。