Fox J, Stahlsmith L, Remington P, Tymus T, Hargarten S
Epidemic Intelligence Service, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Madison, Wisconsin, USA.
Am J Prev Med. 1998 Oct;15(3 Suppl):101-8. doi: 10.1016/s0749-3797(98)00056-7.
Firearm-related injuries rank second only to motor vehicle-related injuries as a cause of injury death in Wisconsin.
To evaluate the attributes of the Wisconsin Firearm-Related Injury Surveillance System.
A structured surveillance system evaluation using predetermined criteria.
A passive surveillance system linking administrative data from existing state-funded inpatient hospitalization and mortality databases.
State health department.
Attributes assessed included simplicity, flexibility, acceptability, sensitivity, predictive value positive, representativeness, timeliness, resources, and data quality.
The use of two existing state databases simplifies data acquisition and linkage. However, hospital discharge and vital records databases are not sufficiently flexible to collect perpetrator and circumstance information. Acceptability is high because of state-mandated reporting to both databases. For firearm-related injuries requiring hospitalization, the system's predictive value positive is 97% when E codes are compared with data from chart reviews. The system is considered timely because annual data from the hospital discharge and vital records systems can be obtained, linked, analyzed, and reported by September of the subsequent year. The system is sustainable largely because existing software is used for annual evaluations, which requires less than 2 weeks of staff time.
With minimal resources and time, the Wisconsin Firearm-Related Injury Surveillance System uses existing state government databases to describe and report the burden of firearm-related injuries. Additional information on circumstances, perpetrators, and weapons involved are available but additional resources are needed to integrate this information with existing data.
在威斯康星州,与枪支相关的伤害是导致伤害死亡的第二大原因,仅次于与机动车相关的伤害。
评估威斯康星州枪支相关伤害监测系统的属性。
使用预定标准进行结构化监测系统评估。
一个被动监测系统,将来自现有州资助的住院患者住院和死亡率数据库的行政数据联系起来。
州卫生部门。
评估的属性包括简单性、灵活性、可接受性、敏感性、阳性预测值、代表性、及时性、资源和数据质量。
使用两个现有的州数据库简化了数据采集和链接。然而,医院出院和生命记录数据库在收集犯罪者和相关情况信息方面不够灵活。由于州政府要求向两个数据库报告,可接受性很高。对于需要住院治疗的枪支相关伤害,当将E编码与病历审查数据进行比较时,该系统的阳性预测值为97%。该系统被认为是及时的,因为可以在下一年的9月获得、链接、分析和报告来自医院出院和生命记录系统的年度数据。该系统在很大程度上是可持续的,因为现有的软件用于年度评估,这需要不到两周的工作人员时间。
威斯康星州枪支相关伤害监测系统只需最少的资源和时间,利用现有的州政府数据库来描述和报告枪支相关伤害的负担。可以获得有关相关情况、犯罪者和所涉武器的更多信息,但需要额外资源将这些信息与现有数据整合。