Witlin A G, Sibai B M
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Texas Medical Branch, Galveston 77555-0587, USA.
Obstet Gynecol. 1998 Nov;92(5):883-9. doi: 10.1016/s0029-7844(98)00277-4.
To review the available evidence regarding efficacy, benefits, and risks of magnesium sulfate seizure prophylaxis in women with preeclampsia or eclampsia.
The English-language literature in MEDLINE was searched from 1966 through February 1998 using the terms "magnesium sulfate," "seizure," "preeclampsia," "eclampsia," and "hypertension in pregnancy." Reviews of bibliographies of retrieved articles and consultation with experts in the field provided additional references.
All relevant English-language clinical research articles retrieved were reviewed. Randomized controlled trials, retrospective reviews, and observational studies specifically addressing efficacy, benefits, or side effects of magnesium sulfate therapy in preeclampsia or eclampsia were chosen.
TABULATION, INTEGRATION, AND RESULTS: Nineteen randomized controlled trials, five retrospective studies, and eight observational reports were reviewed. The criteria used for inclusion were as follows: randomized controlled trials evaluating use of magnesium sulfate in eclampsia, preeclampsia, and hypertensive disorders of pregnancy; nonrandomized studies of historical interest; "classic" observational studies; and recent retrospective studies evaluating efficacy of magnesium sulfate therapy, using relative risk and 95% confidence intervals where applicable. Magnesium sulfate therapy has been associated with increased length of labor, increased cesarean delivery rate, increased postpartum bleeding, increased respiratory depression, decreased neuromuscular transmission, and maternal death from overdose. A summary of randomized, controlled trials in women with eclampsia reveals recurrent seizures in 216 (23.1%) of 935 women treated with phenytoin or diazepam, compared with recurrent seizures in only 88 (9.4%) of 932 magnesium-treated women. Randomized controlled trials in women with severe preeclampsia collectively revealed seizures in 22 (2.8%) of 793 women treated with antihypertensive agents, compared with seizures in only seven of 815 (0.9%) magnesium-treated women.
The evidence to date confirms the efficacy of magnesium sulfate therapy for women with eclampsia and severe preeclampsia. However, there is a need for a randomized controlled trial to determine efficacy of magnesium sulfate therapy for women with mild preeclampsia and gestational hypertension.
回顾关于硫酸镁预防子痫前期或子痫患者惊厥发作的疗效、益处及风险的现有证据。
使用“硫酸镁”“惊厥发作”“子痫前期”“子痫”及“妊娠期高血压”等检索词,检索1966年至1998年2月MEDLINE中的英文文献。检索所得文章的参考文献综述以及与该领域专家的咨询提供了更多参考文献。
对检索到的所有相关英文临床研究文章进行综述。选取专门探讨硫酸镁治疗子痫前期或子痫的疗效、益处或副作用的随机对照试验、回顾性综述及观察性研究。
列表、整合及结果:综述了19项随机对照试验、5项回顾性研究及8项观察性报告。纳入标准如下:评估硫酸镁在子痫、子痫前期及妊娠期高血压疾病中应用的随机对照试验;具有历史意义的非随机研究;“经典”观察性研究;以及近期评估硫酸镁治疗疗效的回顾性研究,适用时采用相对风险及95%置信区间。硫酸镁治疗与产程延长、剖宫产率增加、产后出血增加、呼吸抑制增加、神经肌肉传递减弱及过量用药导致的孕产妇死亡相关。子痫患者随机对照试验的总结显示,935例接受苯妥英钠或地西泮治疗的患者中有216例(23.1%)复发惊厥,而932例接受硫酸镁治疗的患者中仅有88例(9.4%)复发惊厥。重度子痫前期患者的随机对照试验共同显示,793例接受抗高血压药物治疗的患者中有22例(2.8%)发生惊厥,而815例接受硫酸镁治疗的患者中仅有7例(0.9%)发生惊厥。
迄今的证据证实硫酸镁治疗子痫及重度子痫前期患者有效。然而,需要进行一项随机对照试验以确定硫酸镁治疗轻度子痫前期及妊娠期高血压患者的疗效。