Larson E B, Omenn G S, Loop J W
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1978 Jul;131(1):35-40. doi: 10.2214/ajr.131.1.35.
The medical care of 157 patients with suspected cerebrovascular disease was analyzed to assess the impact of the new technology, computed tomography (CT) of the brain, on the care of these patients. A cohort of patients admitted before installation of CT was compared to two cohorts admitted after installation of CT. Length of hospital stay, speed of diagnostic workup, treatment, and discharge plans were not significantly different. Discharge diagnoses were more specific after installation of CT. Lumbar punctures and radionuclide brain scans were used less frequently, but utilization of other diagnostic studies was unchanged. Aggregate charges for diagnostic procedures actually increased in both after-CT groups. In this study, addition of CT to the neurodiagnostic armamentarium resulted in little demonstrable improvement in the care of these patients with cerebrovascular disease but did increase the cost of evaluation. This is unlike the situation for patients with brain tumors, where CT was shown to improve care while not increasing cost. These results may help guide the use of CT by physicians caring for patients with cerebrovascular disease and suggest that health planners not use all patients with cerebrovascular disease in estimating need for CT.
对157例疑似脑血管疾病患者的医疗护理情况进行了分析,以评估新技术——脑部计算机断层扫描(CT)对这些患者护理的影响。将CT安装前入院的一组患者与CT安装后入院的两组患者进行了比较。住院时间、诊断检查速度、治疗及出院计划并无显著差异。CT安装后出院诊断更具特异性。腰椎穿刺和放射性核素脑扫描的使用频率降低,但其他诊断检查的使用情况未变。两个CT安装后组的诊断程序总费用实际上均有所增加。在本研究中,将CT添加到神经诊断手段中,对这些脑血管疾病患者的护理几乎没有明显改善,但确实增加了评估成本。这与脑肿瘤患者的情况不同,在脑肿瘤患者中,CT显示可改善护理且不增加成本。这些结果可能有助于指导治疗脑血管疾病患者的医生使用CT,并表明健康规划者在估计CT需求时不应将所有脑血管疾病患者都考虑在内。