Bret P, Jolivel C, Bret M C, Veylit S, Martin C, Garcia P
Centre Hospitalier Charles Perrens, Bordeaux.
Encephale. 1998 Jul-Aug;24(4):365-77.
Schizophrenia disorders afflict approximately 1% of the population during their lifetime. Conventional antipsychotic agents show therapeutic limitations because of their side-effects and inefficacy among some patients. A novel antipsychotic class, named atypical neuroleptics, among Léponex is the leader, constitutes a hope in treatment-resistant schizophrenia. However, because the drug involves a 1% to 2% risk of agranulocytosis, an haematological oversees has been established. Moreover, the acquisition cost of clozapine is high in comparison with that of standard antipsychotics. The purpose of this study was to observe the management of 72 patients suffering from resistant schizophrenia, to assess the cost of this treatment in medical and social terms, and to realize cost-effectiveness study in Charles Perrens Hospital (Bordeaux). The survey based on three questionnaires (Clinical informations, Quality of Life, Epidemiological information) was sent to psychiatrists practising in this hospital. The results confirm efficacy (overall functioning measured by CGI which is significant, p < 0.0001) and tolerance of Léponex (no side effects in 33.3% patients, no agranulocytosis, only one neutropenia and only 4.2% neurologic side effects). We found a significant reduction of the annual mean number of days of full time hospitalization (214 days versus 135 after two years, p < 0.0005) associated with the significant reduction of direct cost mainly related to shorter length of hospitalization; and 45.8% versus 8.3% adjust to life in the community (p < 0.0004). Clozapine produced a marked improvement (p < 0.0001) in Quality of Life measured by two self-rating scales (SWN and TEAQV). The estimated total two-years cost decreased from 31,108 Francs/month/patient to 22,950 Francs/month/patient, a saving of 8,158 Francs/month/patient (a decrease of 26.2%). Although the acquisition cost of clozapine is high, cost effectiveness estimates in patients with treatment resistant schizophrenia suggest that the clinical benefits (improved psychopathology, social functioning and quality of life) of this drug may confer medium to long term economic benefits, primarily by reducing the need for psychiatric hospital service.
精神分裂症在人群中的终生患病率约为1%。传统抗精神病药物由于存在副作用且对部分患者无效,显示出治疗局限性。一类名为非典型抗精神病药的新型抗精神病药物中,氯氮平是佼佼者,为治疗难治性精神分裂症带来了希望。然而,由于该药物存在1%至2%的粒细胞缺乏症风险,已建立血液学监测。此外,与标准抗精神病药物相比,氯氮平的购置成本较高。本研究旨在观察72例难治性精神分裂症患者的治疗管理情况,从医疗和社会角度评估该治疗的成本,并在波尔多的夏尔·佩伦斯医院开展成本效益研究。基于三份问卷(临床信息、生活质量、流行病学信息)的调查被发送给在该医院执业的精神科医生。结果证实了氯氮平的疗效(以CGI衡量的整体功能有显著改善,p<0.0001)和耐受性(33.3%的患者无副作用,无粒细胞缺乏症,仅有一例中性粒细胞减少症,仅有4.2%的神经系统副作用)。我们发现,与主要因住院时间缩短导致的直接成本显著降低相关,全时住院的年平均天数显著减少(两年后从214天降至135天,p<0.0005);适应社区生活的比例从45.8%升至8.3%(p<0.0004)。通过两个自评量表(SWN和TEAQV)测量,氯氮平使生活质量有显著改善(p<0.0001)。估计的两年总成本从每月每位患者31,108法郎降至每月每位患者22,950法郎,节省了每月每位患者8,158法郎(降低了26.2%)。尽管氯氮平的购置成本较高,但对难治性精神分裂症患者的成本效益评估表明,该药物的临床益处(改善精神病理学、社会功能和生活质量)可能带来中长期经济效益,主要是通过减少对精神病院服务的需求。