Hadden R D, Cornblath D R, Hughes R A, Zielasek J, Hartung H P, Toyka K V, Swan A V
Department of Clinical Neuroscience, Guy's, King's, and St Thomas' School of Medicine, Guy's Hospital, London, UK.
Ann Neurol. 1998 Nov;44(5):780-8. doi: 10.1002/ana.410440512.
We performed electrophysiological and serological testing within 15 days of symptom onset on 369 patients with Guillain-Barré Syndrome (GBS) enrolled in a trial comparing plasma exchange, intravenous immunoglobulin, and both treatments. Patients were classified into five groups by motor nerve conduction criteria; 69% were demyelinating, 3% axonal, 3% inexcitable, 2% normal, and 23% equivocal. Six of 10 (60%) patients with axonal neurophysiology had had a preceding diarrheal illness compared with 71 of 359 (20%) in other groups. Antiganglioside GM1 antibodies were present in a higher proportion of patients with axonal physiology or inexcitable nerves than other patients. The number dead or unable to walk unaided at 48 weeks was greater in the group with initially inexcitable nerves (6 of 12, 50%) compared with the rest (52 of 357, 15%), but was not significantly different between the axonal (1 of 10, 10%) and demyelinating (44 of 254, 17%) groups. Sensory action potentials and clinical sensory examination were both normal in 53 of 342 (16%) patients, and these "pure motor GBS" patients were more likely than other GBS patients to have IgG antiganglioside GM1 antibodies and to have had preceding diarrhea but had a similar outcome. The axonal group was more likely than other groups to have normal sensory action potentials. The outcomes in response to the three treatments did not differ in any subgroup (including patients with pure motor GBS or preceding diarrhea) or any neurophysiological category.
我们对369例吉兰 - 巴雷综合征(GBS)患者在症状出现后的15天内进行了电生理和血清学检测,这些患者参与了一项比较血浆置换、静脉注射免疫球蛋白以及两种治疗方法的试验。根据运动神经传导标准,患者被分为五组;69%为脱髓鞘型,3%为轴索性,3%为不可兴奋型,2%为正常型,23%为不确定型。10例轴索性神经生理学患者中有6例(60%)之前有腹泻病史,而其他组359例中有71例(20%)有腹泻病史。与其他患者相比,轴索性生理学或神经不可兴奋的患者中抗神经节苷脂GM1抗体的比例更高。最初神经不可兴奋的组在48周时死亡或无法独立行走的人数(12例中的6例,50%)高于其他组(357例中的52例,15%),但轴索性组(10例中的1例,10%)和脱髓鞘组(254例中的44例,17%)之间无显著差异。342例患者中有53例(16%)的感觉动作电位和临床感觉检查均正常,这些“纯运动型GBS”患者比其他GBS患者更有可能有IgG抗神经节苷脂GM1抗体且之前有腹泻,但预后相似。轴索性组比其他组更有可能有正常的感觉动作电位。三种治疗方法在任何亚组(包括纯运动型GBS或之前有腹泻的患者)或任何神经生理学类别中的疗效均无差异。