Karakiewicz P I, Bazinet M, Aprikian A G, Tanguay S, Elhilali M M
Department of Urology, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
Urology. 1998 Dec;52(6):1041-6. doi: 10.1016/s0090-4295(98)00350-1.
To assess the 30-day mortality rate and overall survival after radical retropubic prostatectomy (RRP).
Identification of all RRPs performed in the Province of Quebec between January 5, 1988 and January 16, 1996 was accomplished through the Quebec Healthcare Plan Database.
Four thousand nine hundred ninety-seven RRPs were performed by 104 urologists. Overall, 451 deaths were recorded: 32 occurred during the first 30 days (0.6% 30-day mortality rate). A significant decrease in the 30-day mortality rate, from 2.45% to 0.5%, was recorded during the span of the study. The year of surgery, patient age, and hospital type were statistically significant short-term mortality variables (life table analysis). Patient age and year of surgery determined the cumulative survival probability (univariate and multivariate Cox analysis). Cumulative survival at 31 months of follow-up increased from 88.2% in 1988 to 98.1% in 1995. Men 75 years old and older were at a clear disadvantage with regard to survival probability compared with their younger counterparts.
In this population-based analysis of RRP outcomes, we demonstrated a significant improvement in short- and long-term outcomes, as evidenced by a decrease in the 30-day mortality rate and an improved cumulative survival, recorded over the span of the study. The recorded outcome trends may be explained by improved patient selection and optimal management. Although we are unable to determine cancer-specific outcomes, the results of this analysis should prove valuable to urologists and patients until there are results from randomized trials.
评估耻骨后根治性前列腺切除术(RRP)后的30天死亡率和总生存率。
通过魁北克医疗保健计划数据库识别1988年1月5日至1996年1月16日期间在魁北克省进行的所有RRP手术。
104名泌尿科医生共进行了4997例RRP手术。总体而言,记录到451例死亡:32例发生在头30天内(30天死亡率为0.6%)。在研究期间,30天死亡率从2.45%显著下降至0.5%。手术年份、患者年龄和医院类型是具有统计学意义的短期死亡变量(生命表分析)。患者年龄和手术年份决定了累积生存概率(单变量和多变量Cox分析)。随访31个月时的累积生存率从1988年的88.2%增至1995年的98.1%。与年轻男性相比,75岁及以上男性在生存概率方面明显处于劣势。
在这项基于人群的RRP手术结果分析中,我们证明了短期和长期结果有显著改善,研究期间30天死亡率下降和累积生存率提高即为此佐证。记录到的结果趋势可能归因于患者选择的改善和优化管理。尽管我们无法确定癌症特异性结果,但在有随机试验结果之前,该分析结果对泌尿科医生和患者应具有重要价值。