Mills A C, McSweeney M, Lavin M A
School of Nursing, Saint Louis University, MO 63104-1099, USA.
J Prof Nurs. 1998 Nov-Dec;14(6):335-43. doi: 10.1016/s8755-7223(98)80075-6.
Many authors have described differences between nurse practitioners and physician assistants. Most studies have compared physician with nonphysician providers' practice. Few studies have compared nurse practitioners and physician assistants, and none has used a national data base. This exploratory, atheoretical research examined which of the following characteristics predicted patients being seen by nurse practitioners and physician assistants: patient and hospital demographics, diagnosis, diagnostic/screening services, therapeutic services, and disposition of the visit. The data set used for analysis was the 1992 National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey. Based on a multistage probability design yielding national estimates for patient visits in hospital outpatient settings, the National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey showed that there were 2,847 weighted patient visits to either nurse practitioners or physician assistants (4.6 million patient visits using national estimates). Results of multivariate logistic regression suggest that nurse practitioners were the most likely nonphysician provider for outpatients receiving more health promotion and counseling (therapeutic) services and for those needing women's and children's services. Outpatients in rural areas predicted visits to physician assistants. As more nonphysician providers enter the work force, the results of this research may assist with understanding the utilization of nurse practitioners and physician assistants in primary care.
许多作者都描述了执业护士和医师助理之间的差异。大多数研究比较了医师与非医师医疗服务提供者的执业情况。很少有研究比较执业护士和医师助理,且没有一项研究使用过全国性数据库。这项探索性的、无理论基础的研究考察了以下哪些特征能够预测患者会由执业护士和医师助理诊治:患者和医院的人口统计学特征、诊断、诊断/筛查服务、治疗服务以及就诊结局。用于分析的数据集是1992年全国医院门诊医疗护理调查。基于一种多阶段概率设计得出医院门诊环境中患者就诊情况的全国性估计值,全国医院门诊医疗护理调查显示,有2847次加权患者就诊是由执业护士或医师助理提供服务(使用全国性估计值则为460万次患者就诊)。多变量逻辑回归结果表明,对于接受更多健康促进和咨询(治疗)服务的门诊患者以及那些需要妇女和儿童服务的患者而言,执业护士是最有可能的非医师医疗服务提供者。农村地区的门诊患者更倾向于由医师助理诊治。随着越来越多的非医师医疗服务提供者进入劳动力队伍,这项研究的结果可能有助于理解执业护士和医师助理在初级保健中的利用情况。