Sözüer E M, Akyürek N, Kafali M E, Yildirim C
Erciyes University, Medical Faculty, General Surgery Department, Kayseri, Turkey.
Eur J Emerg Med. 1998 Jun;5(2):231-4.
Diagnostic peritoneal lavage (DPL) is an accepted method for evaluating patients with suspected intra-abdominal injury, especially in those with blunt abdominal trauma for whom early operative intervention may be life-saving. To evaluate this method in blunt abdominal trauma victims, we prospectively studied 2010 patients with blunt abdominal trauma who underwent DPL between 1978 and 1996 in our emergency department (at the regional tertiary university medical centre). The patients were then divided into three groups based on their DPL results. Of the total of 2010 patients, 719 (35.8%) met the criteria for positive DPL, indicating the need for laparotomy; 1213 (60.3%) had a negative DPL; and the remainder (78 patients, 3.9%) had equivocal DPL results. All the patients with positive DPL underwent emergency laparotomies which were therapeutic in 547 (76.1%) and non-therapeutic in 156 (21.7%) who had intra-abdominal haemorrhage. Sixteen patients out of 719 (2.2%) had no organ injuries in explorative laparotomy. When the 2010 cases in this study were evaluated, overall rates of specificity, sensitivity and positive predictive rates were found to be 87.3%, 96.3% and 76.1% respectively; the false positive rate was 23.9%, the false negative rate 1.8% and the negative predictive value 98.2%. Complications related to DPL developed in 31 patients (1.5%) out of the 2010 undergoing DPL. It is evident from the results that DPL is a reliable method. However, the criteria for positive DPL should be re-assessed based on the fact that the method itself had a false positivity rate of 23.9% leading to unnecessary operations.
诊断性腹腔灌洗(DPL)是评估疑似腹腔内损伤患者的一种公认方法,尤其是对于腹部钝性创伤患者,早期手术干预可能挽救生命。为了评估该方法在腹部钝性创伤受害者中的应用,我们前瞻性研究了1978年至1996年间在我们急诊科(地区三级大学医学中心)接受DPL的2010例腹部钝性创伤患者。然后根据DPL结果将患者分为三组。在总共2010例患者中,719例(35.8%)符合DPL阳性标准,表明需要进行剖腹手术;1213例(60.3%)DPL结果为阴性;其余78例(3.9%)DPL结果不明确。所有DPL阳性的患者均接受了急诊剖腹手术,其中547例(76.1%)手术治疗有效,156例(21.7%)有腹腔内出血但手术无效。719例中有16例(2.2%)在探查性剖腹手术中未发现器官损伤。当对本研究中的2010例病例进行评估时,发现总体特异性、敏感性和阳性预测率分别为87.3%、96.3%和76.1%;假阳性率为23.9%,假阴性率为1.8%,阴性预测值为98.2%。在接受DPL的2010例患者中,有31例(1.5%)发生了与DPL相关的并发症。结果表明DPL是一种可靠的方法。然而,鉴于该方法本身有23.9%的假阳性率导致不必要的手术,DPL阳性标准应重新评估。