van Geloven A A, Luitse J S, Hoitsma H F
Onze Lieve Vrouwe Gasthuis, afd. Algemene Heelkunde, HM Amsterdam.
Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd. 1998 Sep 5;142(36):2003-6.
Evaluation of the treatment of patients with abdominal complaints at the first aid department of a city hospital, where patients were treated by emergency doctors (EMD) in combination with specialists.
Retrospective, descriptive.
Onze Lieve Vrouwe Gasthuis, first aid department, Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
Data were collected on diagnosis, treatment and course in 3235 patients with abdominal complaints seen at the first aid department in 1997. Non-referred patients were treated by EMD who if necessary consulted a specialist. Referred patients were seen by specialists.
Of the 2931 patients who visited the first aid department once, 1975 patients (67%) were seen after self-referral. Of this group, 1557 patients (79%) were treated by the EMD alone and could be sent to the general practitioner (GP) without consulting a specialist. These accounted for 53% of the 2931 patients with abdominal complaints. The EMD used fewer additional tests than the specialist. Of the patients, 91% could be treated conservatively, only 9% were operated. Fifty-three patients died. Analysis of the group of 304 patients who visited the first aid department more than once in the year of study, showed that in 28 cases the diagnosis was missed (in 17 cases by the EMD and in 11 by the specialist). Of this group 23 had to be operated upon.
The organisation of a first aid department like that in the OLVG, with EMDs and specialists, appeared efficient; the rates of morbidity, mortality and missed diagnoses are acceptable. With relatively few additional tests, the EMD appeared to be able to differentiate between GP care and hospital care.
评估一家城市医院急诊科对腹痛患者的治疗情况,该科室由急诊医生(EMD)联合专科医生对患者进行治疗。
回顾性、描述性研究。
荷兰阿姆斯特丹的翁泽利夫弗劳韦加斯医院急诊科。
收集了1997年在急诊科就诊的3235例腹痛患者的诊断、治疗及病程数据。未转诊患者由急诊医生治疗,必要时急诊医生会咨询专科医生。转诊患者由专科医生诊治。
在2931例仅就诊一次急诊科的患者中,1975例(67%)为自行转诊而来。在这组患者中,1557例(79%)仅由急诊医生治疗,无需咨询专科医生即可转诊至全科医生(GP)处。这些患者占2931例腹痛患者的53%。急诊医生使用的额外检查比专科医生少。91%的患者可采用保守治疗,仅9%的患者接受了手术治疗。53例患者死亡。对研究年度内就诊超过一次急诊科的304例患者进行分析,结果显示有28例漏诊(急诊医生漏诊17例,专科医生漏诊11例)。该组中有23例患者不得不接受手术治疗。
像OLVG医院那样由急诊医生和专科医生组成的急诊科组织似乎很高效;发病率、死亡率和漏诊率均可接受。急诊医生通过相对较少的额外检查似乎就能区分全科医疗和医院治疗。