Carlson D S
Am J Phys Anthropol. 1976 Nov;45(3 PT 1):467-84. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.1330450308.
Much of the earlier work on the prehistory of Sudanese Nubia has emphasized discontinuity between early Nubian populations. However, recent investigations suggest the converse - that a remarkable degree of cultural and biological continuity exists among indigenous Nubian groups, perhaps as far back as the Paleolithic. Thus, cultural and biological differences between Nubian populations can be most effectively perceived as the result of in situ evolutionary development. The present analysis has two major purposes: (1) to describe the morphological differences in the craniofacial complex between indigenous Nubian populations extending from the A-Group (c. 3,400 B.C.) through the Christian (c. 1,500 A.D.) horizons; and (2) to account for these differences within an evolutionary framework. The multiple discriminant analysis of radiographically derived variables revealed a trend from a substantially lower and more elongated cranial vault to a shorter and taller vault throughout the almost 5,000 year time span. Associated with this pattern was a tendency for the face to become more inferiorly-posteriorly located with respect to the vault in the latter groups. Finally, the masseter and temporalis muscles underwent a reduction and slight relocation through time. We speculate that this trend may be associated with behavioral changes associated with transition from a hunting and gathering to a totally agricultural subsistence pattern.
早期许多关于苏丹努比亚史前史的研究都强调早期努比亚人群之间的不连续性。然而,最近的调查结果却相反——表明在当地努比亚群体中存在着显著程度的文化和生物连续性,这种连续性或许可以追溯到旧石器时代。因此,努比亚人群之间的文化和生物差异最有效地被视为原地进化发展的结果。本分析有两个主要目的:(1)描述从A组(约公元前3400年)到基督教时期(约公元1500年)的当地努比亚人群颅面复合体的形态差异;(2)在进化框架内解释这些差异。对通过放射成像得出的变量进行的多重判别分析显示,在近5000年的时间跨度内,存在一种从颅骨穹窿明显更低且更长到更短且更高的趋势。与这种模式相关的是,在后一组人群中,面部相对于颅骨穹窿的位置有更向下向后移动的趋势。最后,咬肌和颞肌随着时间推移出现了萎缩和轻微移位。我们推测,这种趋势可能与从狩猎采集到完全农业生存模式转变所伴随的行为变化有关。