Jones B, Garside S
RACGP Training Program, Queensland.
Aust Fam Physician. 1999 Jan;28 Suppl 1:S41-5.
To assess if the impact of teaching preventive medicine can be increased by supplementing conventional teaching with a practice based preventive audit undertaken by general practice registrars and their supervisors.
A practice based medical record audit of preventive activities was undertaken by 30 general practice registrars and 27 of their supervisors. Items recorded were based on the RACGP's Guidelines for Preventive Activities in General Practice. Participants were also asked to identify or target areas identified by the audit which they specifically wished to improve. Following an educational program on preventive medicine for both groups, the audit was repeated to assess changes made.
Both registrars and supervisors increased their level of prevention in most parameters measured. Registrars' scores were lower than supervisors' for all items in the initial audit but they made greater improvements by the repeat audit (p < 0.02 for all items). There was great variability between the level of recording of preventive data--from rubella immunity (which was recorded in only 22% of cases) to blood pressure (which was recorded in 94% of cases). There was also variability between practices. Items specifically targeted for improvement by participants did not improve more than other items.
Supplementing conventional teaching with a practice-based audit improved the level of preventive medicine undertaken in teaching practices, by both registrars and supervisors.
评估通过由全科实习医生及其带教老师开展基于实践的预防性审核来补充传统教学,是否能增强预防医学教学的效果。
30名全科实习医生及其27名带教老师对预防性活动进行了基于实践的病历审核。记录的项目基于皇家澳大利亚全科医生学院的《全科医疗预防性活动指南》。参与者还被要求确定或指出审核中他们特别希望改进的领域。在对两组人员进行预防医学教育项目后,重复进行审核以评估所做的改变。
在大多数测量参数方面,实习医生和带教老师的预防水平均有所提高。在初次审核中,实习医生在所有项目上的得分均低于带教老师,但在重复审核时他们的进步更大(所有项目p<0.02)。预防性数据的记录水平差异很大——从风疹免疫(仅在22%的病例中记录)到血压(在94%的病例中记录)。不同诊所之间也存在差异。参与者特别针对改进的项目并没有比其他项目改进得更多。
通过基于实践的审核来补充传统教学,提高了实习医生和带教老师在教学诊所中开展预防医学的水平。