Douglas M W, Parsons C M, Hymowitz T
Department of Animal Sciences, University of Illinois, Urbana 61801, USA.
Poult Sci. 1999 Jan;78(1):91-5. doi: 10.1093/ps/78.1.91.
This study evaluated the nutritional value of raw lectin-free soybeans in comparison with raw Kunitz trypsin inhibitor-free soybeans, raw conventional soybeans, and commercial heat processed soybean meal (SBM). Analyzed lectin values (milligrams per kilogram) were 7.2, 7.1, and < 0.00015 for the Kunitz-free, conventional, and lectin-free soybeans, respectively. Three experiments were conducted using New Hampshire x Columbian male chicks fed 23% CP dextrose-soybean diets from 8 to 17 d of age. Growth performance of chicks fed lectin-free soybeans was greater (P < 0.05) than that of chicks fed raw conventional soybeans in all three experiments. However, performance of chicks fed lectin-free soybeans was lower than that of chicks fed Kunitz-free soybeans or SBM. The SBM yielded weight gains and feed efficiencies that were much higher than those observed from any of the raw soybeans. True amino acid digestibility and TMEn of the lectin-free and conventional soybeans were determined using the precision-fed cecectomized rooster assay. Seven roosters were crop-intubated with 30 g of soybeans and excreta were collected for 48 h. Digestibility coefficients of most amino acids for lectin-free soybeans were 5 to 8 percentage units higher than those for conventional soybeans, but the differences were not significant (P > 0.05). Likewise, the TMEn for lectin-free soybeans was 11% higher than that for raw conventional soybeans (3.577 vs 3.227 kcal/g DM) but the difference was not significant (P > 0.05). The results of this study indicate that the nutritional value of raw lectin-free soybeans is greater than raw conventional soybeans but is less than raw Kunitz-free soybeans and SBM, suggesting that trypsin inhibitor is a greater antinutritional factor than lectins.
本研究评估了无凝集素生大豆与无库尼茨胰蛋白酶抑制剂生大豆、普通生大豆以及商业热加工豆粕(SBM)相比的营养价值。无库尼茨大豆、普通大豆和无凝集素大豆的分析凝集素值(毫克/千克)分别为7.2、7.1和<0.00015。使用新罕布什尔×哥伦比亚雄性雏鸡进行了三项试验,从8日龄至17日龄饲喂含23%粗蛋白的葡萄糖-大豆日粮。在所有三项试验中,饲喂无凝集素大豆的雏鸡生长性能均高于(P<0.05)饲喂普通生大豆的雏鸡。然而,饲喂无凝集素大豆的雏鸡性能低于饲喂无库尼茨大豆或豆粕的雏鸡。豆粕产生的体重增加和饲料效率远高于任何一种生大豆。使用精确饲喂的去盲肠公鸡试验测定了无凝集素大豆和普通大豆的真氨基酸消化率和真代谢能。七只公鸡嗉囊插管饲喂30克大豆,并收集48小时的排泄物。无凝集素大豆的大多数氨基酸消化率系数比普通大豆高5至8个百分点,但差异不显著(P>0.05)。同样,无凝集素大豆的真代谢能比普通生大豆高11%(3.577对3.227千卡/克干物质),但差异不显著(P>0.05)。本研究结果表明,无凝集素生大豆的营养价值高于普通生大豆,但低于无库尼茨生大豆和豆粕,这表明胰蛋白酶抑制剂是比凝集素更大的抗营养因子。